Wed 9 Apr 2008
According to recent news reports, perhaps a sliver of relief is on the way for the price of rice. Apparently there is a bumper boro crop this year (see here. This, plus the expected arrival of imported rice, has apparently caused the price rises to cease, at least for now (see here). This is certainly welcome news.
But there are still serious grounds for worry. According to the Financial Times, rice prices rose more than 10 per cent last week as rice importing countries (including Bangladesh) tried to secure supplies from the handful of exporters still selling the grain in the international market. The price jump came as leading exporting countries including Vietnam, India, China and Egypt, banned foreign sales.
This Economist article says: Asia’s masters may need a new green revolution, if they want to avoid upheavals of a bloodier hue. Bangladesh is not mentioned, but the warning is appropriate for us too. In the long run, there is no alternative for us but to raise our own production. But long run is pretty far away. Is there anything that can be done here and now?
Last year I noted that one reason why our food prices started rising in 2003-04, couple of years earlier than the global food price inflation, was because of the depreciation of taka against the Indian rupee (see here). What I did not stress then was the magnitude of the depreciation in more recent months.
The chart below shows that taka depreciated by around 20 paisa against the rupee since the beginning of 2007.
In addition to the global factors (see here) and the natural disasters, this depreciation alone could have sent our food market into a frenzy. Does anyone have any idea what caused this sharp depreciation last year?
And can it be reversed? Can Bangladesh Bank intervene in the foreign exchange market to assist an appreciation of the taka? The chart below shows that the Bank has record reserves, so it is better placed to prop up the taka today than ever before.
To be sure, taka-rupee exchange rate will not bring down rice prices to 2006 levels, let alone the ‘golden days’ of 2000. Among other things, officially India is not exporting rice, so the exchange rate shouldn’t affect rice prices at all. But if there was ever a time when the market forces and the porous Indo-Bangla border can work towards our advantage, that time is now. Extralegal rice imports aside, we do import a lot of other food items from India whose prices are also skyrocketing (see here about daal). Any taka appreciation will definitely affect the prices of these items. And more importantly, the appreciation will affect expectations about future prices (see this for a discussion on the role of expectations).
And taka appreciation could also affect exports, and possibly investment if a monetary tightening is required. But how serious could those impacts really be? I argued last year that exports boomed in the past few years because of global boom, not undervalued taka. Surely any impact of a taka appreciation on exports would be overshadowed by whatever happens in the US and other developed economies. And as for domestic investment, is financial costs of borrowing the main hindrance to business activities in today’s Bangladesh? Anecdotal evidence points to confidence issues arising from political situation as a much bigger factor.
Maybe there are other strong arguments against a taka appreciation. If so, I’d very much like to hear them. I’d also like to understand what caused the depreciation since last year.
April 10th, 2008 at 12:23 pm
When I watch the various “pundits” comment on rising prices of essentials many of them fail to point out that rising grain prices is a global phenomenon.
I have recently come back from Thailand and for the past 4 days the headline of Bangkok Post has been about rising price of rice. The army is being mobilised in Thailand to guard against hoarding.
Even today British PM Gordon Brown urged action on rising food prices.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/uk_news/politics/7339954.stm
The author of this thread sidesteps real reasons for the soaring prices of rice and gets into trivial theories like taka/rupee exchange rate.
The simple reason why rice is expensive because rice prices have gone up worldwide due to many factors like - high fuel prices, limited number of countries who produce rice, many countries have banned export of rice fearing local shortage.
As Bangladesh does not grow enough rice and has to import rice from abroad, it must by rice at international prices. The only thing the government can do is to provide subsidy, which it is doing with the BDR run fail price shops.
Rice prices have doubled in the last twelve months and it is a fact. For Bangladesh it is not a result of the anti corruption drive, jailing of politicians or doom or gloom as many politicians and “round table” commentators would like us to believe.
I am disappointed at so called “rountable panels” and political leaders who are trying to blame the government for the price rise for their own selfish motive. Either that or they are simply too naive or not well informed.
Again there is no reason specific to Bangladesh why rice prices have risen. Yes if we did not have floods and cyclones our production would be higher and prices a bit lower but ultimately the local price would reflect global market conditions.
Below are some links regarding this issue:
http://www.bloomberg.com/apps/news?pid=20601087&sid=ahaT0.5kV1JI&refer=home
Article from BBC.
http://news.bbc.co.uk/2/hi/south_asia/7324596.stm
April 12th, 2008 at 8:43 pm
Well, this is not a this-year phenomenon as World Bank President Robert Zoellick put it recently.
Worldwide commodity price increase, weak dollar and ever-growing population are some factors in this crisis.
Expect more food riots around the world and increased food prices in the coming years.
Unfortunately, again Bangladesh is one of the most vulnerable countries with its 150 million people.
April 12th, 2008 at 9:06 pm
Indian media reports riots over food crisis in Bangladesh joyfully… they never mention who engineered this apart… it was them…
April 19th, 2008 at 1:04 pm
Xanthis,
You are apparently a disciple of the school of thought that believes that if there is anything wrong in BD, it must be India’s fault.
If you would care to read any of the publications referenced above and do some bare bones analysis, you would find it hard to disagree that the current food crisis is a global one. Sadly, this time around the combined effects of rapid population growth, decreased cultivable land, increased fuel prices are going to make it a prolonged phenomenon and one from which it would not be easy to come out anytime soon.
April 19th, 2008 at 11:37 pm
Mamoon,
We have pointed out the macroeocnomic causes of food price inflation in UV and in the print media - some of the links are provided above.
But the government is directly responsible for the situation in Bangladesh in 2 regards:
1. The demolition drive that happened immediately after the coup last year, and the broader anti-corruption witch hunt, has deeply affected business in the country. Activities, including trading activities, have slowed. Among other things, this means less employment and slower income growth in the informal and less skilled sectors of the economy. For example, the rural or mofussil business men have simply shut shops and stopped employing. Why does it matter? Well, at a time when rice price has doubled, not having job matters a lot. And this is a mess that is of the government’s making.
2. Food prices were rising before 1/11, and the popular story of ‘this is because of the syndicates run by Tarek-Mamoon-Falu’ was a misdiagnosis of the problem. Instead of probing the underlying macroeconomic reasons, the government went for the populist, and in my opinion politically-motivated moves of ‘locking up the crooks’.
Nonetheless, the purpose of this post was not to berate the government. The reality is, food prices have sky rocketted, and while the growth is abetting, they still remain very high. So the question is, can anything be done about it?
I suggested a possible solution. Is it feasible? That discussion is the point of this post, not political point-scoring about the regime or politicians.
August 29th, 2008 at 3:36 pm
Bangladehs can be self sustainable in food production is we apply certain principles in the country and use what we have. \
I invite everyone to read it and I’m hoping Drishtipat.org would publish my article on this blog.
http://garamblog.com/2008/08/28/bangladesh-can-be-self-sustainable-in-food-production/