Sat 22 Sep 2007

Perhaps the rest of my days will be spent in this deep agony. Because, that time has come in my life— the time of old age when Shamsur Rahman began to regret everything. We will not live to see a good time. At the time of January 11, I dreamed that such a time would really come to this country. But, what was supposed to happen, and now what is happening? Why couldn’t I bring those words out of the deepest provinces of my heart: please don’t go, stay with us, this country will have its time as well.
Please Don’t Go
- Mamunur Rashid
(translated from Bengali)
[Prothom Alo, Sep 22, 2007]
Dear reader, first let me beg your forgiveness. In today’s column I will talk about some personal matters.
After dropping his only son at the airport, on his way to the United States, any father feels his throat tighten, many thoughts crowd into his head.
My son came to see his sick mother. After only 21 days, he left again. He studied in America. In that country, he has just taken a job. The job isn’t bad either, but in every moment he wants to return home. He studied film in college. Now he wants to return. Start working on films in this country.
When he first left the country, the BNP coalition had come to power. Ekushey TV was on its way to being shut down. My son used to direct a docu-magazine on that channel called “Light of Century”. A ten episode series on a century of Bengali history. After 6 episodes, reactionary quarters shut the program. Ekushey TV used to encourage young people. Simon Dring, Farhad Mahmood, AS Mahmood were very focused on this. Even though Nawajish Ali Khan was a media bureaucrat, he had a creative past, so he was involved in this as well. But the BNP coalition government cruelly crushed this channel. My son’s future became uncertain. One day I said goodbye to him at this same Dhaka airport. He needed to get educated during these dark years. When the evil time ends, he can return.
The evil rule ended. But did the uncertainty end? Ekushey TV no longer looks like its old self. The other channels are also broken. My son went back to his workplace. My wife and I said goodbye with tears in our eyes.
My son has a green card, so does my wife. I got the green card, but didn’t take it. Because of that crime, last time I didn’t get a visa to go to the US. I didn’t get to inaugurate the South Asia Theater Festival. New York was in an uproar over this. Protests were led by world famous stage director Richard Shackner. Although, after my wife surrendered her green card, they agreed to give me a visa.
I said, I fought for this country. Why should I become a citizen of another country? What future would I have there anyway? I don’t think they understood me. When so many people are dying for a green card, why wouldn’t I take it?
Anyway, a feeling of guilt chases me all day. Why wasn’t I able to say to my son “don’t go.”
My son studied at one of Dhaka’s best school. When he was in class seven, I asked him: if you become ruler of this country, what would you do? He replied, “First, I would shut down my school!”
I was scared when I heard his reply. He had good results in school. Later he was admitted to a good college. But he didn’t like any of it. He started liking education only after he went to America. His favorite place became his school, even though he was now much older. The school where he graduated also became the site for his first job.
I remember my village school. When I came to Dhaka to go to college, I cried into my pillow every night. I cried for that school’s teachers, students, the dumur tree next to the school, the canal, the fast-flowing river. Why didn’t my son have the same fate?
Why couldn’t this generation have a single fond memory for villages, schools, Dhaka city, anybody? He never saw endless fields, empty horizon, the gorgeous beauty of rain, the open hearts of simple village folk. Instead he witnessed dictator Ershad’s greedy, half-mad times. Then he saw a white terror in the name of democracy. Then, he came back this time to see another time of uncertainty.
His favorite Maloy kaka and Anwar chacha in jail. The affection he grew up with now missing. Whenever he came back to the country, Maloy kaka would call him repeatedly, would come and see him.
My wife is very sick. She very badly needs to be near her son. But still, after all this, I couldn’t bring myself to say “please stay.”
Perhaps the rest of my days will be spent in this deep agony. Because, that time has come in my life— the time of old age when Shamsur Rahman began to regret everything. We will not live to see a good time. At the time of January 11, I dreamed that such a time would really come to this country. But, what was supposed to happen, and now what is happening? Why couldn’t I bring those words out of the deepest provinces of my heart: please don’t go, stay with us, this country will have its time as well.
And yet, at the very beginning of this journey, that was the dream we all saw.
[Mamunur Rashid is a playwright and actor]
September 22nd, 2007 at 10:27 pm
This article reflects our sadness at the state of our country.
September 23rd, 2007 at 12:53 am
For all those who left friends and families to develop ourselves into human machines for the U.S. economy, we are getting ready for the country of our birth. Our parents made and everyday make the sacrifice of “deep agony” so we can one day make a real difference to out nation. Let us not forget how young a country we are. Let us not forget that in preparation there is much virtue. Its looks pretty hopeless now, if we stay steadfast and patient , the clouds will clear and a promising future we will preserve for the next generation. All good things takes time to develop. The test is in the journey, not the destination. Be patient and do your part; as parents sacrifice, so do children in foreign countries. There will be a time when we will look back at this time and recognize the huge strides Bangladesh is making. Young people in diaspora can make a huge impact for Bangladesh, we are preparing so as things change we can be there to help.
September 23rd, 2007 at 1:16 am
For all the son’s who have left home. ( Writer unknown).
“From home you have reached
the Horizon here.
From here to another
here you go.
From there to the next
next to the next
horizon to horizon
every step is a horizon.
Count the steps
and keep the number.
Pick the white pebbles
and the funny strange leaves.
Mark the curves
and cliffs around
for you may need
to come home again.”
September 23rd, 2007 at 4:22 am
Well said, Naima. Let us not be despondent.
Masroor,(speaking for myself)do please keep the poetry coming! It is great to have somebody like you who is able to give voice to his thoughts and feelings through the rich poetry that our ancestors have bequeathed us.
September 23rd, 2007 at 7:24 am
After 18 years in the U.S.A I came back home to stay here permanently. 1st 6 months I was up-bit but now I regret it very much and wished I had not come back. I feel hopeless in every step of the way mostly due to corruption and lack of respect for humanity and huge mass of unmanagable people.
September 23rd, 2007 at 10:35 am
Nuzat,
Just to remind all–H.M.Ershad former President known for his dictorial rule also loved Poetry,both writing and reciting- what a paradoxical situation that it was during his time that the bullet pierced the heart of the boy who had Give me DEMOCRACY (hope its the right word)inscribed on his body.
Hitler it is said indulged in poetry and music during his spare moments.
Manur Rashid aptly describes the feelings of all parents whose children are abroad becauuse we dont have a proper educational system and a process for getting the right job according to qualification and merit.Additionally there is traditionally racist feelings between professionals here- as to whether or not you had been a FF or not 0R as to whether u had been baptized by the Mujib Government across the border– that was the main reason why from the beginning of Independence right people couldnt be placed at the right job and therefore today the exodus of so many Bangladeshis to foreign countries.
Naima,
Its good to know that you all are getting ready for the country of yr birth- meaning you all should be coming soon here.I also got the news fromm other sources that many NRBs are planning to come in too– thats great news no doubt.But to make the difference you would really need a lot of challenging work in first and foremost to change the attitude of the people in respect of what I have mentioned above(read racist feeling…)-this idea has to be fopught to point that all Bangladeshis are patriots and that there does exists qualified persons who can make it to the parliament- if he fails he due ineeficiency he can be removed through the bye-elections–say after two years; but he should be monitored by the Citizen- who must remain active and informed– so villagen and urban level teaching on system is a must.
Mamunur Rashid,
If anybody can covey this message to him: please have patience and pray that yr son excels himself in his profession and soon after Eelctions when things have bewcome better you willm have him back with you here with him contributing to the media in Bangladesh. Also one thing to remember that having a Green Card doesnt mean you r less patriot or qualified to serve the country– that Green Card is yr ticket to better place during times when security is poor here. DONT WORRY BE HAPPY.
September 23rd, 2007 at 11:12 am
Thank you, Nuzhat. However, I am not so proud of some of my ancestors and I steal poems from all over.
September 23rd, 2007 at 12:59 pm
Naima: It’s words like yours that we need to keep our spirits up at times like this. Most of us are too busy wallowing in hopelessness than thinking constructively.
September 23rd, 2007 at 2:05 pm
A bittersweet poem of parting and parenting.
My daughter called me after class.
She said she needs a boarding pass.
Fly twenty thousand miles away from home,
She thinks she’s in the twilight zone.
I’m trying hard to cut the strings,
To help her stretch, to give her wings,
Encouraging her motivation
To go for higher education.
“Just wait till Eid,” I reply.
I Give that old trick a try.
Baba, I just can’t take another day.
Please, please! Don’t make me stay!”
I found an e-mail from my kid.
“You’ll never believe what I just did!”
My little girl, the great protestor,
Lasted through the whole semester!
That was four long years ago,
When everything was touch-and-go.
This spring, she’ll graduate, and then,
She’ll marry one of those college men.
Someday, her daughter will call and say,
“Ma, I can’t take another day.”
She’ll take a breath and answer sincerely,
“Honey, I loved college dearly.”
September 23rd, 2007 at 2:54 pm
Masroor, when I used the word ancestors, I was alluding to the common ancestry that we enjoy with fellow human beings at large! I think most of us would hate to be in a world where we had to be parochial about something like poetry.
Feel free to grab poetry from anywhere in the world. You honour the poet and the humanity that is common to all of us.
September 23rd, 2007 at 11:07 pm
The title of this thread “Please Don’t Go” is the sad story of Bangladesh - where istead of planning for building the nation - the whole motivation for doing ANYTHING in BD, (whether higher Education, job, learning, devt, training, govt etc) is just - HOW TO GET OUT OF BANGLADESH, and migrate somewhere else.
Anywhere - Greece, Tasmania, Iceland, Oman, Sudan, Germany - even where the lingo twists the tongue like a tornado in Texas! - anywhere is better than Bangladesh! Just Get a degree and get the hell out - just any visa will do!! That seems to be the national motto - in UNivs, schools, roads and bazaars.
This results in a national policy - of how to gear the colleges and govt to EXPORT BRAINS, export bodies and export buddhijibis.
This leaves the nation in a total vacuum, void of any policy for development, repair or rebuilding for the future. “If our sons and fathers are leaving - why bother to build the nation - let IT go to hell too” !!
Besides, “since the problem is as mega as the mega population, there is no hope anyway” “so lets loot and poot as much as possible - while our sons and daughters get their degrees to fly”!! That was the nation-builder politicians’ viewpoint.
So while the author cried for his sons and asked then to return to BD - did he ever try to IMPROVE the nation in any way that would motivate them to return?
The tragedy is - why they have to leave the nation in the first place? Why not DEVELOP the universities and LIFESTYLE to such standards, that not only the sons will return, but the GRANDSONS WILL RETURN TOO to Bangladesh, for higher studies, and to rebuild the nation.
September 24th, 2007 at 6:46 am
I think that time has come to serve our country while we live in outside of Bangladesh. I predict better future for Bangladesh if we stop being pessimistic.
We need to cheer up others to move back in Bangladesh with projects which will help Bangladesh and own personal financial conditions. This is the right time if anybody ever dreams to be back home.
Many will disagree with my prediction but its my hope and its my prayer.
Best wishes,
M. M. Chowdhury, USA
http://www.amreteck.com
September 24th, 2007 at 8:54 am
KGazi #11
“So while the author cried for his sons and asked then to return to BD - did he ever try to IMPROVE the nation in any way that would motivate them to return?”
You obviously do not know the playwright Mamunur Rashid, otherwise you wouldn’t have asked this question.
He has done much for the country. Maybe you would like to reflect on what you have done instead.
Most of your questions are addressed in his article, if you choose to read it a little more carefully.
Farhad
September 24th, 2007 at 9:10 am
KGazi, you are right! We should toil to create better Bangladesh (DEVELOP the universities and LIFESTYLE to such standards) so that you and your posterity can return and enjoy.
September 24th, 2007 at 2:09 pm
Phantom,
I don’t believe anywhere in the article the author mention that having a Green Card makes you less patriot. If he thinks so why would he allow his family to get immigration in the first place? In the point of his own not having a green card he just gave his logic to it, that doesn’t mean who ever takes the immigration to another country are less patriot.
September 24th, 2007 at 5:50 pm
i do love seeing that chap on the TV, very bhodhro and banglavision is one of the few parts of the media that gives my hope.
BUT
he is right. his generation is to blame for failing to do better than it did. they failed to give their kids a sense of continuity and brought them up as chickens in schools of dhaka with a consumerist attitude to nationalism.
he is awfully charming though.
September 24th, 2007 at 6:42 pm
Farhad,
I admit I don’t know much about playwright Mamunur Rashid, but besides reading he “fought for the nation”, I don’t see anything else in the article, that he did later FOR THE NATION to encourage his son’s return. Did he write any plays highlighting the degradation of living conditions in BD, or how the young have a single thought of leaving the country, or how the nation is wrongly mass-producing a brain-drain?
I don’t intend to attack HIM personally for lack of foresight into the nation’s predicament – but I am asking ALL those in BD who have the academic background, the urban planners, the economists, the sociologists with PHD’s and gold medals - where have they been?
It’s no use asking Me what I did to improve the nation, because 1) I am not there, and 2) I personally don’t have that authority. He is much more influence than I do – he has the resources, the access and the authority to bring about change, which I dont. He has the media, the literature, the readership, what action are the literatii taking to bring changes in MINDSET for future of BD society?
We (people of BD) need a national policy that rewards those who stay in BD and those who return, which realizes that losing people is far worse than losing money, and we must do all that is necessary - so that domestic development is the ultimate goal of PRIORITY – through direct investment on our OWN people, and not through indirect remittance from the leftover income of foreign exodus.
September 24th, 2007 at 7:08 pm
Some people are missing the point of this piece. It is not about blaming people or calling NRBs less patriotic. It is not about the desperation that pushes so many NRBs to Malaysia and the Gulf. This piece is about how the best and brightest of our country slowly get disillusioned.
Look at comment #5. Stories like that are commonplace. No we do not mind the fact that the roads are narrow and lined with the symbols of poverty, that there are no Hummer showrooms, that there is no nightlife, that the tap water is undrinkable or that we’re stuck in traffic for hours without movement. All these we NRBs are willing to face.
The real disillusionment starts when you see the following:
1 Hartals and strikes that stop your earning dead
2 Irresponsible statements by authority figures about “sharajantra” that give the country a bad image
3 Little to no social mobility. In the West you might face racism, but at least you have enough to live a decent life and send the kids to school.
4 No freedom for new ideas. Young NRBs are full of new ideas and new initiatives, some good, some bad. Out here in the west, they have freedom to experiment. Back home, they have to think about 20 times about how many people they will end up offending with their ideas or whose interest they are treading on: will the local MP mama mind my venture? what about thegeneral chacha? what about the imam of the mosque? What if the government finds tht its losing revenue and shuts me down?
That is just 4 things. Now ask yourself how many of these are beyond the ctg’s control, how many they’ve improved and how many they’ve made worse.
September 24th, 2007 at 7:57 pm
Mr K Gazi
Seriously, before you continue blogging a lot about this issue, please try to watch some of the TV dramas he wrote. I am not a big fan of Actor Mamunur Rashid, but I miss his dramas (written/directed).
When you say “but besides reading he “fought for the nation”, I don’t see anything else in the article, that he did later FOR THE NATION to encourage his son’s return” , you realy do not appear smart. Why should he beat his own drum?
Many of our previous generation want us to be back. But there is probably not suitable environment for the NRBs to be back. On the other hand, even if you make a Heaven on Earth (hope I do not offend anyone) in Bangladesh they will not be back.
September 24th, 2007 at 11:54 pm
KGazi #16
I don’t know what to say.
“It’s no use asking Me what I did to improve the nation, because 1) I am not there, and 2) I personally don’t have that authority.”
So the onus is on the people who stay back in the country, while we can only shower valuable advice on them. Maybe he should have left the country with his son; he would not have then shouldered such a burden of responsibility.
Maybe we will find the answers if we ask ourselves why we don’t go back. I understand, like me, you live abroad too. It is much better here. Until they sort it out back home why go.
Farhad
September 25th, 2007 at 4:06 am
For a long time, I have been thinking that blogging and writing in English makes DP tend to be dominated by an elite and/or out-of-touch NRB group. We just have to look at Sachalayatan, a blog in Bengali, to see the dramatic contrast with DP in terms of age, language, class background, location, etc. These are the young Bangalis I run into in Mirpur, Mohammedpur, Shyamoli, Badda, Adabor. Hustling, trying to make a living, and yet concerned and patriotic.
By contrast every time I open DP, I feel I hear the voices of suburban NRBs who live in Maryland or Bethesda or Poughkeepsie. Now all of the above is a massive generalization. There are many on DP who don’t fit my simplistic formula. I am just talking about a feeling I get at times.
Especially when I read what KGazi posted above.
I am astounded to see a regular, prolific DP blogger who does not know who Mamunur Rashid is. He is only one of the 5 most prominent actors of the post-71 generation, and one of the most influential playwrights and directors. All told he has probably acted in thousands of hours of TV/stage drama. There is an entire generation of acting that has grown up around him, Aly Zaker, Humayun Faridi, Raisul Islam Asad, Lucky Inam, Pijush Bandopadhyay, etc. If you list the ten most influential personalities in TV/Stage/Film, MR is one of those ten.
How can someone not know who Mamunur Rahid is, and be blogging with such authority about BANGLADESH?
September 25th, 2007 at 7:01 am
A very Interesting link that shows how the Indians are benefitting from the Expats and on the other hand not a single intiative has been taken by any BD government in the history of 36 years state running, that a single Expatriates was given a single opportunity to implement their ideas and plan openly.Nor a single example of Expats accomodation was ever heard by any government intiatitive.
We have to do it ourself, can’t wait for the government any more.
http://newdelhi.usembassy.gov/snap06expat.html
Hope you might enjoy the link.
Thanks
Kawser Jamal
September 25th, 2007 at 8:12 am
I didn’t read Mamunur Rashid’s article in its original form, but I found the translation posted by DP quite moving. As a father of a young boy, I too can imagine myself, 10-15 years from now, suffering the same kind of agony that MR is going through. But perhaps not all of the agony is necessarily about having to see one’s son go abroad because of lack of appropriate opportunities or environment in one’s ‘own’ country. Don’t parents feel the same kinds of pangs when they marry their daughters off, or when young men leave their village or small town homes for study or work even inside their own country?
Those of you who seem somewhat guilt-ridden because of your being away from Bangladesh, yet are deeply concerned about the country, I would like to say this: there is no need to feel the guilt, nor to fantasize about all the contributions you could make if you found yourselves in a position to return to BD. As someone who studied and lived in the US for eight years, but chose to return to the country (due no less to ‘push’ factors in the US than the ‘pull’ of home) in the end, I feel that ultimately it probably makes litte difference for BD whether people like us return home or settle abroad. What matters is what you do with your longing for the land you still call home. But one must also rise above sentimental attachments to a piece of land, and view things in a more global perspective.
I do wonder about some things though: what my life would have been like if I had stayed in the US, or if I had not gone there in the first place…! But these are things one will never know. What I do know is that as individuals we are free to make choices, and must make choices, but just because one has migrated out of Bangladesh, or opted to return home eschewing opportunities available abroad, gives one no moral upper ground to speak about matters relating to the ‘home country’. So those of you NRBs who may be feeling a bit low having read Mamunur Rashid’s article, please cheer up, but stay tuned to what’s going on inside BD!!!
September 25th, 2007 at 8:44 am
Dear all,
I am grateful to all who have participated in the discussion. The comments have illuminated my ideas. This article is not at all an analysis of our socio economic condition rather just a feeling of a lonely moment. I had no intention to undermine the green card holders or NRBs. They could immensely contribute to our countries development. Now also they are the main source of our Foreign Exchange. I have also many friends who are serving abroad in high positions. They also expressed their desire to come back and work for the country, some came back but could not stay because they were not appreciated.. Still my intention is, let us all try to make Bangladesh habitable for all of us creating opportunity to hundred flowers bloom. The job has been made difficult by all powerhouses in the past backed by first world countries and their financial organizations.
I have told of ETV, and they have shown how much power was hidden in the people and the youth. So it was necessary for the power clique to break ETV In consequence many lost initiatives and S. A. Mahmud had to embrace early death. The late Mr Mahmud told my son that you must go back, remember that’s your workplace. The evil political force did not allow this patriot’s dead body to lie in Bangladesh. What ever is the situation my son is coming back to join us.
For Mr Gazi, I have an humble submission that besides Political struggle there was also a strong movement from cultural activists specially the theatre movements .Bangla theatre is now known all over the world. You can browse and find information if you desire. I am fortunate that I am one of the initiator of this movement I have tried to reflect the struggle of the toiling masses and their aspiration in theatre and media.
I am again thankful to you all
Mamunur Rashid
September 25th, 2007 at 3:32 pm
I don’t know with moral authority someone can demand to know what others have contributed to the country when he himself has moved away abdicating his responsibility. Some people have made a choice to stay abroad. Let’s be at peace with it. But them blaming the people who stayed back for the ills in the country borders into complete outrage and ridiculousness.
The question is really fair that someone who is so out of touch with the happenings in Bangladesh, can send out prescription for its problems. The answer is that they absolutely can. But whether they are to be taken seriously is all the more a different matter.
September 26th, 2007 at 8:28 am
Mamunur Rashid (#23):
Thank you for your graceful and moving reply. As a parent, I saw what you meant (and what Prashanta alluded to in #22) in the original article: the sadness and longing as you say goodbye to your child. It really is irrelevant whether they’re going to another country or next door. All that matters is that they are going away.
In your case, and with your background in Bangladesh, it must be even sadder to have him leave the country, especially for the reasons he is leaving for.
At this point, all I can do is sympathize. And all we can do is hope that he does come back. But if he doesn’t, make him promise that he will have the courage to face his decision and not to belittle his country for it.
No country deserves that ignominy.
September 27th, 2007 at 1:20 am
Nuzhat, Sorry for the late reply. Sometimes my work ( mountain climbing ) restricts me to get
back to a computer at night. ( I fall asleep).
Point understood and my feelings are very similar.
Thanks.
September 27th, 2007 at 1:39 am
Dear Mr Mamunur Rashid,
In your article I sensed a much deeper concern (which I am familiar with), than just an emotional moment. There is a severe erosion of national values and opportunities for people, a negative feeling which is making people leave Bangladesh.
That’s why I was curious to know if you or anybody in Bangladesh had highlighted the problems related to your sad experience. Nobody in this blog came forward to reply whether you had written any plays on Brain Drain and Mass Exodus out of Bangladesh, or not.
Thank you for responding on this blog, giving us the rare opportunity to communicate directly with a national artist. I appreciate and salute your achievements, although having left Bangladesh as a youngster in 1971, I lost track of the Natok Scene (which I loved) and was not familiar with your work, which I regret.
Even after 36 years out of the country, I still spend many long hours like most NRB’s, on issues related to Bangladesh. I also migrated back to Bangladesh once from UK, in the mid-80s with my young family, but after 3 years again left, because of two major problems in BD which I couldn’t handle. One was excessive corruption, and the other was the total lack of
national policy on human development and retention of local talent.
The whole country was being run as if there was a disaster-evacuation going on! and people were scrambling to run away from the country, in any way they could – to take shelter in safer grounds. I even saw many parents PUSH their children out of the country in the process – sometimes against the child’s wish.
Because there is this national (government) drive to get as many people out as possible, to maximize remittance, I believe a serious VACUUM is created through national policy-making, regarding development of people and nation, for domestic growth of those who are already living there, resulting in a desperation of hopelessness in BD citizen to leave the country, and worse – a massive degradation of Bangladesh as we knew it.
So for you as an artist intellectual in the country, I sense that you may have a huge responsibility to GUIDE the Policy Makers, through your work, to reverse that thinking – and put emphasis on making Bangladesh more
attractive for growth of our young people today, especially talented students, artists, scientists, etc. That, I think will encourage more people to stay, more to return and more to develop inside Bangladesh.
September 27th, 2007 at 11:17 am
MR’s writing was about the eternal tenderness of parting. To me, everything else was just contextual reference, just a backdrop. It is beyond politics, beyond socio-economic conditions. The pain would have been same if MR were in haven and the son were leaving for Bangladesh.
Though MR has shown a commitment in his writing to a particular philosophy, it is not essential. It will be devastating to demand great authors to write on “my issues”. Such a demand is a total failure to understand the inherent nature of creativity. It is like questioning Michael Jordan’s athleticism for his inaction/inability/unwillingness to become African-American political voice.
No offense to NRBs; Bangladesh is not lacking talents in any sector. Massive brain drain though not desirable, still not a big problem for the country. We need Bangladesh more than Bangladesh needs us.
September 27th, 2007 at 6:51 pm
SC #29, “Bangladesh is not lacking talents in any sector. Massive brain drain though not desirable, still not a big problem for the country. We need Bangladesh more than Bangladesh needs us.”
—–
There you go - thats exactly the mentality in Bangladesh that I am talking about. The policy in BD is that they dont need anybody - they have enough, and this comment reflects exactly my point.
India produces 100’s of 1000s of PHD’s per year and they believe its not enough, they need more. they are now hiring talent from USA and UK. Bill Gates went to BD and told the authority he will fund millions to produce more IT graduates in Bd - because there is virtually NONE.
Even in garments there are thousands of “consultants” working in BD from diffrent countries - and yet local Bangladeshis are leaving!
And here SC reflects the attitude of Bangladesh national mentality - he says just like BD national mentality - “we dont need any talent in BD”, we have enough!? so let the graduates leave. And that is reflected also in DU grads, 70% are doing their degrees to leave the country!
Perhaps we can ask the question to MR’s son (and millions others who left the country) just as matter of interest, how THEY feel about staying in BD, and the level of acceptance for their skills there.
September 27th, 2007 at 8:05 pm
#29 SC
reading your post I recall there is a saying in Bengali ” Fata kolsi baje beshi”. Pokete nai futa poisa but hambora vaab jaina kokhonoy.
September 27th, 2007 at 9:13 pm
KGazi #28 & #30
You really don’t get the point, do you. You keep on asking:
“Nobody in this blog came forward to reply whether you had written any plays on Brain Drain and Mass Exodus out of Bangladesh, or not.”
“So while the author cried for his sons and asked then to return to BD - did he ever try to IMPROVE the nation in any way that would motivate them to return?”
What if the answer to your question is that ‘no, he didn’t write any such plays’ ? Does it not then entitle him to feeling pain for his son leaving, just as you feel sad not being able to go back and stay in your country in spite of having done nothing yourself to help the situation there. The fact that he has written great plays (some on the social condition in the country) don’t make any difference ?
Please understand it was a very personal statement about how he felt about his son leaving and has not / or need not anything to do with how you feel about your country. I don’t know if you even realize how sanctamonious you sound. If you did you would be embarrased yourself.
You write:
“Even after 36 years out of the country, I still spend many long hours like most NRB’s, on issues related to Bangladesh.”
And at the same time:
“I admit I don’t know much about playwright Mamunur Rashid, but besides reading he “fought for the nation”, I don’t see anything else in the article, that he did later FOR THE NATION to encourage his son’s return.”
Is it anybody’s fault that you know so little in spite of the ‘many long hours’ spent in ‘understanding’ Bangladesh ?
Farhad
September 28th, 2007 at 2:06 am
#Mr. KGazi
Sure, 36 years a long time to take your “Bangladeshi” mentality away. Please read carefully, “not lacking talents” does not mean we do not need anymore, specially the REAL ones. Look at the economists we have here, look at our rich cultural front. In education, we have people who are achieving a great lot with a faction of the facilities that educators get in other places. We have young entrepreneurs who are competing internationally with limited resource. We have two and half intern doctors treating few hundred ER patients everyday and keeping most of them alive! Even in politics, some of them may be crook, but many of them are far more talented, well-versed than average NRB.
Mr. bd watcher(#31), I hope you did not refer to our talent pool as a “faka kolsi”, hopefully you just meant me.
Indian booming economy needs cutting edge research, hence they need more Ph.D.s in the relevant sectors. The current state of BD technology and institutional research does not need hundreds of thousands of PH.Ds. They will probably be burden rather than resource at this stage.
Now, Mr. Kgazi, look at your naked hypocrisy:
KGazi to MR for failing to IMPROVE the nation
#11. So while the author cried for his sons and asked then to return to BD - did he ever try to IMPROVE the nation in any way that would motivate them to return?
#17. but besides reading he “fought for the nation”, I don’t see anything else in the article, that he did later FOR THE NATION to encourage his son’s return.
(This was not MR’s resume though)
KGazi with his lame excuses
#28. I also migrated back to Bangladesh once from UK, in the mid-80s with my young family, but after 3 years again left, because of two major problems in BD which I couldn’t handle. One was excessive corruption, and the other was the total lack of
national policy on human development and retention of local talent.
Therefore, MR and his colleagues have to take the shit and have the responsibility to make the country livable for KGazi.
KGazi on Artist’s responsibility
#11. Did he write any plays highlighting the degradation of living conditions in BD,
#29. So for you as an artist intellectual in the country, I sense that you may have a huge responsibility to GUIDE the Policy Makers, through your work, to reverse that thinking – and put emphasis on making Bangladesh more
attractive for growth of our young people today
Though MR has always written in favor of his left leaning philosophy that is not the point here. You are dictating that every creative artist has the responsibility of being a social reformer. That will be enough to crush the intellectual development of a human society, the ultimate dictatorship! Now, I think Bangladesh is better off by exporting few ‘talents’.
September 29th, 2007 at 9:26 am
Mamunur has inimitable magic.Kudos.