Thu 10 May 2007

Daily Star journalist, CNN stringer, Human Rights Watch researcher, and Blogger Tasneem Khalil was picked up by Joint Forces Thursday night, and released 24 hours later. They also took his 2 computers and mobile phone. Tasneem was chief researcher on HRW’s in=depth report on RAB “Judge, Jury & Executioner” and has written about torture-murder of Adivasi activist Choles Ritchil, extra-judicial killings, etc.
Update 11:1:00 pm BDT (Sat)
Amader Shomoy reports DGFI’s Rumi has been transferred.
Update 10:8:51 am BDT (Sat)

Prothom Alo has a small item @ bottom of front page. New Age covers well. Nothing in other papers. BDNews24.com has posted a scan of Mahfuz Anam’s statement.
Update 9:11:33 pm BDT (Fri)
Tasneem is meeting with Mahfuz Anam in his office alone. Staffers in office say he looks physically ok, but badly shaken up. He is being taken home to his wife by DS staff after the meeting with MA.
Update 8:11:15 pm BDT
Tasneem Khalil released by joint forces, almost 24 hours after being picked up. No news on whether 2 computers and mobile phone were returned.
Update 7:10:15 pm BDT
Senior Daily Star office are huddled in office, including Mahfuz Anam. MA has released a statement. Excerpts: ” “I contacted the authorities concerned and was informed that him being questioned was not due to his journalistic work and had nothing to do with his functions at The Daily Star….In fact, it was because of the contents of his personal blog and some SMSs he had sent recently…..”
Update 6:5:50 pm BDT
Many people don’t have internet access as today holiday, so the strategic decision to arrest him night before weekend helped to impose partial news blackout. SMSs still flying, but no new update. Shockingly, still nothing posted on Daily Star or BDNews24, even though they have other breaking news. So they have decided to sit on it. Also note, Reuters quotes Zafar Sobhan, but not Mahfuz Anam– editor of the DS.
Update 5: 3 PM BDT
Tasneem has been allowed to telephone wife briefly. Associate Press quotes Zafar Sobhan
Update 4: 1 PM BDT
CNN carrying it as main header
http://www.cnn.com/2007/WORLD/asiapcf/05/11/bangladesh.journalist/index.html
CNN and HRW have been in contact with Bangladesh’s Special Envoy to the United States, Farook Sobhan, and other officials.
Update 3: 8:49 AM BDT
All diplomatic missions in Dhaka were informed of the arrest this morning. They are sending back updates to home country. Fakhruddin Ahmed has also been informed.
Update2: 7 AM BDT
news is spreading fast in international media.
Update 1: Human Rights Watch has issued an alert
Army Arrests Tasneem Khalil of Human Rights Watch
(London, May 11, 2007) – Bangladesh’s military-backed care-taker government should immediately release Tasneem Khalil, an investigative journalist and part-time Human Rights Watch consultant, who was detained by security forces late last night, Human Rights Watch said today.
We are extremely concerned about Tasneem Khalil’s safety. He has been a prominent voice in Bangladesh for human rights and the rule of law, and has been threatened because of that.
Khalil, 26, is a journalist for the Dhaka-based Daily Star newspaper who conducts research for Human Rights Watch, and is stringer for CNN. According to his wife, four men in plainclothes who identified themselves as from the “joint task force”came to the door after midnight on May 11 in Dhaka, demanding to take Khalil away. They said they were placing Khalil “under arrest” and taking him to the Sangsad Bhavan army camp, outside the parliament building in Dhaka.
“We are extremely concerned about Tasneem Khalil’s safety,” said Brad Adams, Asia director at Human Rights Watch. “He has been a prominent voice in Bangladesh for human rights and the rule of law, and has been threatened because of that.”
The men did not offer a warrant or any charges, Khalil’s wife said. Using threatening language, they searched the house and confiscated Khalil’s passport, two computers, documents, and two mobile phones.
“It is an emergency; we can arrest anyone,” one of the men said. Another asked if Khalil suffered from any particular physical ailments. They drove Khalil off in a Pajero jeep.
Khalil is a noted investigative journalist who has published several controversial exposes of official corruption and abuse, particularly by security forces. He assisted Human Rights Watch in research for a 2006 report about torture and extrajudicial killings by Bangladesh security forces.
According to Bangladeshi human rights groups, the army has detained tens of thousands of people since a state of emergency was declared on January 11, 2007. A number of those detained are picked up in the middle of the night, as Khalil was, and then tortured.
In Bangladesh, security forces have long been implicated in torture and extrajudicial killings. The killings have been attributed to members of the army, the police, and the Rapid Action Battalion (RAB), an elite anti-crime and anti-terrorism force. The Human Rights Watch report Khalil worked on, “Judge, Jury, and Executioner: Torture and Extrajudicial Killings by Bangladesh’s Elite Security Force,” focused on abuses by the RAB.
Killings in custody remain a persistent problem in Bangladesh. To date, no military personnel are known to have been held criminally responsible for any of the deaths.
Khalil was called in for questioning by military intelligence last week, apparently as part of the military’s campaign to intimidate independent journalists ahead of May 10, 2007, when the army’s three-month legal mandate for ruling under a state of emergency came to an end.
“The Bangladeshi military should be on notice that its actions are being closely watched by the outside world,” Adams said. “Any harm to Tasneem Khalil will seriously undermine the army’s claims to legitimacy and upholding the rule of law.”
DP Petition
To: The Honourable Chief Adviser of the Non-Party Caretaker Government and Advisers of Ministries
Drishtipat is highly concerned at the arrest and detention of Tasneem Khalil, a journalist and human rights activist. Khalil, 26, works for the Daily Star, and is associated with international organizations of repute such as Human Rights Watch and CNN. He is a staunch defender of human rights and an outspoken critic of human rights abuses.
In the early hours of 11 May, four men without uniform, identifying themselves as part of the “joint forces”, came to Khalil’s door and took him away to the Sangsad Bhaban army camp. No warrants were shown, nor were any charges made against him. According to witnesses, they confiscated his property, including passport, two computers, documents, and two mobile phones, again without showing cause.
We have welcomed your Government’s drive against corruption, your plans for reform and your support for Bangladeshi expatriates having a greater voice in the running of their country. Drishtipat is an organization of Bangladeshi expatriates and we urge you to investigate the causes and conditions of his detention and ensure justice and humane treatment for Tasneem Khalil, against whom no suspicions, let alone charges, of corruption were ever made. If there are no charges against him, we urge that he is released immediately. Further, we strongly condemn such arbitrary arrests and other attempts at intimidating the media, since it runs counter to the very reform your Government want to see.
The Drishtipat Team.
May 10th, 2007 at 8:11 pm
Is this clutching at straws for a government that is being questioned increasingly, or is it a more ominous sign of a section of the army trying to come out to the forefront of action? Either way, this is atrocious!!
May 10th, 2007 at 8:24 pm
Time to stop this nonsense.
This will be escalated to the highest possible level, I can promise you that.
May 10th, 2007 at 9:24 pm
I condemn this arrest. Let’s do something for him.
May 10th, 2007 at 9:39 pm
Outrageous. Simply outrageous. How fractured are the lines of authority in the CTG?
May 10th, 2007 at 9:54 pm
Time is of the essence here. It’s time to spread the news far and wide.
May 10th, 2007 at 10:12 pm
As regards human rights violation, this government is even worse than BNP-Jamat!
May 10th, 2007 at 10:12 pm
It’s simply brutal. The army just cannot get away with these despotic acts. It’s time they are stopped!!
May 10th, 2007 at 10:38 pm
I condemn this. Lets spread the news. Tasneem has to be saved.
May 10th, 2007 at 10:56 pm
J jekhane thaken Jege Uten!
Inform all the Human Rights Organization worlwide.
May 10th, 2007 at 11:05 pm
[...] Drishtipat [...]
May 10th, 2007 at 11:30 pm
Click on the following link and scroll down to update:2 for a London based reporter’s report on Tasneem’s arrest (emailed by Tasneem’s wife)
http://keepmehonest.wordpress.com/2007/05/10/outrageous/
May 10th, 2007 at 11:43 pm
*Dear All*
*This is Sharmin Afsana Shuchi, wife of Tasneem. He has been arrested,
picked up in the middle of the night by the joint forces. Spread the
word,
please support him in anyway you can. Tasneem Khalil |
tasneem.khalil@gmail.com | http://www.tasneemkhalil.com
*
*For Immediate Release*
*Bangladesh**: Release Journalist and Rights Activist*
*Army Arrests Tasneem Khalil of Human Rights Watch *
(London, May 11, 2007) – Bangladesh’s military-backed care-taker
government
should immediately release Tasneem Khalil, an investigative journalist
and
part-time Human Rights Watch consultant, who was detained by security
forces
late last night, Human Rights Watch said today.
Khalil, 26, is a journalist for the Dhaka-based *Daily Star* newspaper
who
conducts research for Human Rights Watch. According to his wife, four
men in
plainclothes who identified themselves as from the “joint task
force”came to
the door after midnight on May 11 in Dhaka, demanding to take Khalil
away.
They said they were placing Khalil “under arrest” and taking him to the
Sangsad Bhavan army camp, outside the parliament building in Dhaka.
“We are extremely concerned about Tasneem Khalil’s safety,” said Brad
Adams,
Asia director at Human Rights Watch. “He has been a prominent voice in
Bangladesh for human rights and the rule of law, and has been
threatened
because of that.”
The men did not offer a warrant or any charges, Khalil’s wife said.
Using
threatening language, they searched the house and confiscated Khalil’s
passport, two computers, documents, and two mobile phones.
“It is an emergency; we can arrest anyone,” one of the men said.
Another
asked if Khalil suffered from any particular physical ailments. They
drove
Khalil off in a Pajero jeep.
Khalil is a noted investigative journalist who has published several
controversial exposes of official corruption and abuse, particularly by
security forces. He assisted Human Rights Watch in research for a 2006
report about torture and extrajudicial killings by Bangladesh security
forces.
According to Bangladeshi human rights groups, the army has detained
tens of
thousands of people since a state of emergency was declared on January
11,
2007. A number of those detained are picked up in the middle of the
night,
as Khalil was, and then tortured.
In Bangladesh, security forces have long been implicated in torture and
extrajudicial killings. The killings have been attributed to members of
the
army, the police, and the Rapid Action Battalion (RAB), an elite
anti-crime
and anti-terrorism force. The Human Rights Watch report Khalil worked
on,
“Judge, Jury, and Executioner: Torture and Extrajudicial Killings by
Bangladesh’s Elite Security Force,” focused on abuses by the RAB.
Killings in custody remain a persistent problem in Bangladesh. To date,
no
military personnel are known to have been held criminally responsible
for
any of the deaths.
Khalil was called in for questioning by military intelligence last
week,
apparently as part of the military’s campaign to intimidate independent
journalists ahead of May 10, 2007, when the army’s three-month legal
mandate
for ruling under a state of emergency came to an end.
“The Bangladeshi military should be on notice that its actions are
being
closely watched by the outside world,” Adams said. “Any harm to Tasneem
Khalil will seriously undermine the army’s claims to legitimacy and
upholding the rule of law.”
*To view the December 2006 Human Rights Watch report, “Judge, Jury, and
Executioner: Torture and Extrajudicial Killings by Bangladesh’s Elite
Security Force,” please visit: *
http://www.hrw.org/reports/2006/bangladesh1206/
*For more information, please contact:*
In Mumbai, Meenakshi Ganguly (English, Hindi, Bengali):
+91-98-200-36032
(mobile)
In London, Brad Adams (English): +44-20-7713-2767; or +44-79-0872-8333
(mobile)
In New York, Fred Abrahams (English, German): +1-212-216-1281; or
+1-917-385-7333 (mobile)
In Washington, DC, Sam Zarifi (English): +1-202-612-4354;
+1-646-662-7750
(mobile)
–
May 10th, 2007 at 11:47 pm
Dear All,
I know a lot of you are working behind the scene. Please do keep the word of protest coming in. I received an email from him just three hours ago where he informed that he was constantly under surveilance.
Our thoughts and prayers with the family. Spread the word far and wide.
May 10th, 2007 at 11:54 pm
Asif, we are on it. It was heartening to see the HRW press release. I hope to see the Washington Post article tommorrow. CNN needs to cover it since he is their representative in Bangladesh.
May 11th, 2007 at 12:03 am
I’ll do what I can to spread the word. Tasneem regularly sent me links to his articles; I think of him as a friend. This is appalling.
May 11th, 2007 at 12:07 am
Incomprehensible!
I suppose we could never jettison the mantle inherited from Pakistan and we continue to model after ‘that’ dysfunctional setup.
There goes the aftermath of glow that I came back with from Dhaka- as I boarded the plane on January 13th.
May 11th, 2007 at 12:18 am
To stop a journalist they always choose the the easyest way, Arrest! Shame!shame! shame!
May 11th, 2007 at 1:24 am
This could be the proverbial last nail in the coffin.
What is this government thinking? By carrying out such acts, it is inviting unnecessary attention and international outrage. It is about to lose its face.
It would also mean that we are closer to reverting back to the “golden” days of the two genuine democratic ladies, sooner than we want to.
God ! will someone tell them to act sensibly.
May 11th, 2007 at 1:28 am
Beastly and cowardly. Still am in disbelief. May Allah be with him and his family.
May 11th, 2007 at 2:05 am
[...] Voices: Drishtipat group Blog urges: Please show your outrage against this outrageous attempt to curb freedom of speech. THIS SIMPLY [...]
May 11th, 2007 at 2:29 am
Truth continues to be a casualty of this war. This type of repression on journalists, human rights activists and progressive politicians cannot go on for too long. These shady midnight-knockers don’t have the guts and honor that Tasneem has.
I’m glad that HRW picked up on it quickly, it will start getting media coverage. A lot of people around the world are watching with a lot of concern.
May 11th, 2007 at 2:40 am
[...] bloggers covering: Drishtipat, Global Voices, Rezwanul, Golmal Sid, Salam Dhaka, Keep me honest, My dear Bangladesh, Adda, Deshi [...]
May 11th, 2007 at 2:59 am
I have an update in my blog.
May 11th, 2007 at 3:09 am
This is not acceptable. We must make this clear to the government and the joint forces. Let’s go for a petition drive and press all the levers.
May 11th, 2007 at 3:21 am
I am not sure what benefit the arrest of Mr. Khalil would provide to the interim government.
I have read many articles on news dailies like Amader Shomoy which are very critical of the current government but as far as I know, no journalist has been detained by the joint forces since the emergency was declared, other than the editor of Janakantha on corruption charges.
Mr. Khalil is quite well known among the blogging community but not a very well known or influential name in Bangladesh media. So it is highly unlikely that he was arrested to make a point or as a warning to other journalist.
It doesn’t make sense.
I however would deplore his detention if it was done to harass him for his journalistic work.
May 11th, 2007 at 3:39 am
I could not wait and decided to send this open letter to the daily star:
—————————————–
Dear Honorable Chief Adviser:
Many of us expatriates are extremely concerned about the recent arrest by
the joint forces of Tasneem Khalil of human rights watch. He is the brave
journalist who reported on abuses by certain joint forces personnel.
Most recently, he reported on the inhuman torture and killing of the Garo
leader Choles Ritchil by some joint forces personnel.
Under this circumstances, we strongly suspect that his arrest is connected
to his reporting. We ask your honor to investigate this matter without
delay and use your enormous influence to effect the immediate release of
this brave journalist.
This kind of intimidation speaks much louder that words and sends the
wrong image across the world about Bangladesh and its current government.
We do not find this acceptable, and we hope you will concur. It goes
completely against the spirit of your statement that a free press will
hold your government accountable.
For a sampling of the expatriate reaction, you may check the popular
website http://www.drishtipat.org/blog
Sincerely
Saleh Ahmed Tanveer
Professor of Mathematics
The Ohio State University
Columbus, OH 43210
May 11th, 2007 at 4:22 am
This is really a shameful work of the arm forces. Tasneem is a journalist and not any criminal, that they can pick him up and lock him down for no proof or reason.
Regardless of my previous rift with Tasneem on a small issue, I condemn this arrest and want a clear report why and who are behind this journalist arrest? He is a out-spoken and a opend minded journalist, which we need the most in Bangladesh. Journalism without fear and favour. He was writing on lot of critical issues of the country and educating the people in Bangladesh and abroad a lot.
My prayers are with him and I think a petition for his release should immediately be sent for all the people to sign the petition.
thanks
Kawser Jamal
http://www.changeBangladesh.com
May 11th, 2007 at 4:23 am
The man who has been courageously exposing the brutal human rights abuses by the state agencies has now himself become one of the victims. This is incredible!! Tasneem Khalil is a friend of the powerless - the minority communities and the downtrodden. We must condemn his arrest and stop this tyranny.
May 11th, 2007 at 4:25 am
Basically Tasneem was really worried about the whole episode. I know when he was student of Class Xii. He is a young energetic boy. I know that Tasneem who was one of the Master of widely popualr red hat.
In DP I found him after long time and He has becoming such a big journalist. we are really proud of him now. Now To every one
who writes in blog should support this young boy.
May 11th, 2007 at 4:27 am
We from Change Bangladesh and I Kawser Jamal personally condemn this arrest of Tasneem Khalil.
Regardless of a small rift between Tasneem and me, I respect and admire his journalism.I will always support the truth, even if I don’t like the person or party speaking the truth. Tasneem has lot of potential mission critical reports those were making lots of corrupt people disturbed and I was praising his writing than and would do forever.
Thanks
Kawser Jamal
Our Prayers are with you Mr Tasneem.
A online petition for his release should be going on for people to sign their name and send to the Care taker government.
May 11th, 2007 at 4:37 am
Ok this government has just really crossed the border. Enough is enough! We have to get down on the streets and really do something. We really need the international attention now. They better not touch a hair of this brave journalists. What an irony that we just celebrated World Press Freedom Day. Its all %^$^&&.
May 11th, 2007 at 4:38 am
CNN Wire is running the arrest news.
[see Update #5 in the following link]
http://keepmehonest.wordpress.com/2007/05/10/outrageous/
May 11th, 2007 at 4:49 am
All diplomatic missions in Dhaka were informed of this arrest this morning (this is probably because he is a CNN correspondent). They are sending back updates, but have been advised to wait before taking any steps.
Fakhruddin Ahmed has also been informed.
Reports say that it is confirmed that it is the army. But the attempt is now for back-channel negotiation to get him released, rather than frontal confrontation.
May 11th, 2007 at 5:03 am
Tasneem on Choles Ritchil Case
Tasneem on Modhupur
http://www.thedailystar.net/forum/2007/march/modhurpur.htm
Tasneem quoted in Washington Post
http://pages.citebite.com/t1c6y7i7k0njn
Tasneem on Sabash Bangladesh!
http://www.drishtipat.org/blog/2005/05/07/sabash-bangladesh/
May 11th, 2007 at 5:18 am
This is outrageous. I’ll also put on all my radors.
My thoughts are with him and his family.
Tahir
May 11th, 2007 at 5:44 am
Rubeal Bhai is Updtaing regularly in his blog
http://salamdhaka.blogspot.com/.
Those who have any update please publish
May 11th, 2007 at 5:45 am
I have posted names and contact info of the Congressional Bangladeshi Caucus members. If you are in the US, please contact your congressman or senator about Tasneem.
http://www.docstrangelove.com/2007/05/10/breaking-reporters-under-attack-in-bangladesh/
May 11th, 2007 at 6:00 am
Tasneem is a rare and gifted journalist - utterly courageous and fearless, in a great line of investigative journalists, whose inspiration comes from the John Pilgers, Robert Fisks and Seymour Heshes of this world. This move is to be utterly condemned. This is a call to action from everyone who visits this site.
May 11th, 2007 at 6:44 am
High traffic American blogs have picked up Tasneem’s story.
Taylor Marsh has posted an appeal in a comprehensive post about Tasneem:
http://www.taylormarsh.com/archives_view.php?id=25567
The Moderate Voice posted this story:
http://themoderatevoice.com/places/asia/12749/reporter-taken-away-at-night-by-military-in-bangladesh/
And Never In Our Names (NION) has put an appeal for Tasneem’s release (with an image) prominently on their front page sidebar:
http://www.neverinournames.com/frontPage.do
I also posted his story on the NION front page.
I expect and hope more high traffic American blogs will pick up his appeal tomorrow.
May 11th, 2007 at 8:12 am
Tasneem is a role model of courage and honesty in the journalist community-my beleif is that he will emerge stronger and with more credibility after this unfortunate criminal act by the security forces.
May 11th, 2007 at 8:17 am
[...] Tasneem Khalil Picked Up By “Joint Forces” http://www.drishtipat.org/blog/2007/05/10/tasneem-khalil-picked-up-by- army/ [...]
May 11th, 2007 at 8:34 am
[...] Bangladesh: Release Journalist and Rights Activist Published May 11th, 2007 Democracy , State of Emergency , Bangladesh , Security , Politics , Media The army have really made a mistake this time. Just when their puppet leader Fakhruddin Ahmed has been making assurances not to limit the freedom of the press, last night a prominent investigative reporter, Tasneem Khalil was arrested and taken from his home. Already there is uproar [...]
May 11th, 2007 at 8:37 am
Goes to show you can never trust the army with upholding human rights and press freedom. This will only make us stronger in our resolve to speak up against the atrocities being committed by this military/government.
May 11th, 2007 at 9:04 am
This is outrageous! The practice of picking up people in small hours reminds me of Stasi, the dreaded East German secret police. While the campaign to get Tasneem released should be geared up fully, let us not forget the plight of thousands of others who were picked up in a similar manner in the reign of the current CTG.
May 11th, 2007 at 9:19 am
Why isn’t the Daily Star web page or bdnews24 reporting on this news item? Are they being scared off by as well?
May 11th, 2007 at 9:20 am
This is an absolute travesty which needs to come to an end without delay.
May 11th, 2007 at 9:34 am
Moin, good question. One hopes that DS will have the decency to give this story at least a header tomorrow. I don’t know about bdnews24.
May 11th, 2007 at 9:49 am
This is not looking good, shows there are two or more force working without CTG chief acknowledgment. There were few other incidents which suggest lack of communication or common stand with CTG. This government should find out who are those people making the mess and dump them sooner than later. Otherwise the support towards this CTG will take a nose dive in no time.
And yes need a clear explanation from CTG on this arrest without any delay.
May 11th, 2007 at 9:52 am
Organisations exclusively defending the rights and interests of the journalist, including Reporters San Frontiers, should immediately come forward and start a big campaign for his release. As far as I know, RSF played a prominent role when another investigative journalist Saleem Samad and Priscilla Raj were arrested back in … (sorry forgot the year).
May 11th, 2007 at 11:23 am
To: The Honourable Chief Adviser of the Non-Party Caretaker Government
and Advisers of Ministries
Drishtipat is highly concerned at the arrest and detention of Tasneem
Khalil, a journalist and human rights activist. Khalil, 26, works for
the Daily Star, and is associated with international organizations of
repute such as Human Rights Watch and CNN. He is a staunch defender of
human rights and an outspoken critic of human rights abuses.
In the early hours of 11 May, four men without uniform, identifying
themselves as part of the “joint forces”, came to Khalil’s door and
took him away to the Sangsad Bhaban army camp. No warrants were shown,
nor were any charges made against him. According to witnesses, they
confiscated his property, including passport, two computers,
documents, and two mobile phones, again without showing cause.
We have welcomed your Government’s drive against corruption, your
plans for reform and your support for Bangladeshi expatriates having a
greater voice in the running of their country. Drishtipat is an
organization of Bangladeshi expatriates and we urge you to investigate
the causes and conditions of his detention and ensure justice and
humane treatment for Tasneem Khalil, against whom no suspicions, let
alone charges, of corruption were ever made. If there are no charges
against him, we urge that he is released immediately. Further, we
strongly condemn such arbitrary arrests and other attempts at
intimidating the media, since it runs counter to the very reform your Government wants to see.
Drishtipat team
May 11th, 2007 at 11:41 am
Yep, we need to organise some demonstrations outside some embassies. And i quickly checked Amnesty’s site but they obviously haven’t got anything out yet. As mash says, time is of the essence, i don’t trust these military ****ers - this is an OUTRAGE!
May 11th, 2007 at 12:15 pm
I don’t understand one thing. Why is it so difficult for people with minimum understanding that actions like this take them no-where! It is unacceptable to arrest someone who raises voice of dissent or disagreement which every one has a right to. I personally don’t know T.K but stongly feel that he must be released if not held on a specific charge which is against the law. If there is any such charge CTG / Law Enforcement agency must come out clean.
I wish him all the best and am positively hopeful that he will be released very soon. I don’t think CTG has the capability to endure the pressure that is in the process of brewing.
I condemn this act as much as I condemned bar on SH/KZ right to choose where they want to be.
Thanks LTT
May 11th, 2007 at 12:17 pm
[...] bloggers covering: Drishtipat, Global Voices, Rezwanul, Golmal Sid, Salam Dhaka, Keep me honest, My dear Bangladesh, Adda, Deshi [...]
May 11th, 2007 at 12:30 pm
Dear Lopa,
Peace be upon you. Have faith & try stay calm. I pray for his safe return.
May 11th, 2007 at 12:31 pm
Picked Politics are discussing the need to send out an online petition - would it make sense to ask DP to initiate?
May 11th, 2007 at 12:31 pm
UPDATE : The overwhelming empathy for Tasneem Khalil is remarkable. I, however, have got an update from Joint Forces. Tasneem Khalil has NOT been detained for his ‘fearless’ journalism. He has been identified as an individual who was spreading a seditious SMS, a campaign against military in the last few weeks. After a series of investigation about the chain of SMSs, it has been found that Tasneem was the originator. JF decided to know the motive behind such campaign and when asked him today, he confessed and said he was doing it just to get ‘fame’. His boss Mahfuz Anam went to meet the senior JF officials this morning and when Tasneem’s SMS and proofs of other anti-law activities were shown to him, he just escaped declaring his ignorance about those. Mahfuz Anam found it ‘very immatured’ about what Tasneem was doing in the past few days. Tasneem’s confession, apology and promise of not doing any subversive activities in the future are on tape.
Let us not jump on the conclusion whenever you see something you don’t want to see. There could be different explanation which you are not aware of. Thank you.
May 11th, 2007 at 12:37 pm
Many Bloggers at Bangla blogging platform “Bandh Bhanger Awaaj” suspended regular postings and declared that they will only write about Tasneem Khalil today.
May 11th, 2007 at 12:49 pm
ABC,
Since you seem to have a lot of insider information, can you tell us why legal proceedings are not taken against him? Did he have access to a lawyer when he “confessed”? Was there a warrant? Does this mean he is/or will be released soon?
May 11th, 2007 at 1:01 pm
ABC,
Since when is sending an SMS “anti-law”?
Nothing can justify detention without a specific charge. If he has committed a crime the right thing to do is to file a General Diary with the police and/or initiate legal proceedings. It is the lack of due process we are concerned about.
This is still outrageous…under which law is sending an SMS critcizing the government an illegal act? And where does it say that the punishment for such an alleged crime is being picked up from your home in the middle of the night and being forced into confessing your guilt on tape?
May 11th, 2007 at 1:07 pm
Hello, please let us know of the latest. I think it would be good to organise a demonstration in front of the Bangladeshi embassy in London on this Sunday.
If you are interested please see our website - http://www.pickledpolitics.com
May 11th, 2007 at 1:28 pm
Again this raises the issue of who is in control. Particularly ironic since it was just two days ago that Fakhruddin was proclaiming to the foreign press that he was the boss. What are we to make of these claims? Are we to imply therefore that this kidnapping has been done under his aegis? Or is there a parallel power structure over which he has little influence? None of this bodes well.
May 11th, 2007 at 1:29 pm
If you know the truth, you would be ashamed of running after senators, diplomats, editors (who else?). No reasons to demonstrate in front of Bangladesh embassy in London or….
Why do you think DS/PA kept their mouth shut? They know the fact. Tasneem Khalil is much more than what you think. He has got other ‘talents’ and he is describing those to JF. Calm down, he will be released eventually.
May 11th, 2007 at 1:59 pm
Is it the act of some over enthusiast unintelligent members of the army, who steps on snake’s tail assuming it a rope?
Or, has the CTG become a finger-puppet of the army? (The brain should have controlled the bat, not the other way round). I hope the army is not daydreaming about running the country by themselves?
Passing the ward to every sensible person I know. However eagerly waiting to witness another disgraceful defeat of this authority!
May 11th, 2007 at 2:03 pm
“UPDATE 7: Release promised at 9.30 pm Bangladesh time. There will be massive media campaign if this promise does not materialise.”
It speaks poorly of the media and journalists if their voices can be silenced by kidnapping one of their colleagues! The silence from Daily Star is sad and unexpected. I thought they always advocated the right of people to know…
May 11th, 2007 at 2:04 pm
. Wait until few more hours. See what comes out in Daily Star. You expect that it would be the main header. But you will be surprised to see Mahfuz Anam trying to prove that he was not a party to Tasneem on his subversive activities. ‘chacha, aapon pran bacha’.
Apart from his part time journalism, blogging, HR activity, Tasneem Khalil is on the payroll of a number of foreign intelligence agencies. He will be exposed to you all. Please wait for that. Meanwhile, you may keep these messages on hold if you are uncomfortable. You promote freedom of speech, don’t you ???
May 11th, 2007 at 2:21 pm
Credit to Tasneems wife for her quick thinking and getting the news to CNN so speedily! Thanks to her we’ve all been informed of this quite quickly and been able to group together to give our attention and energy getting Tasneem released as quickly as possible. I hope they stick to their word that he will be released at 9.30 unharmed!
May 11th, 2007 at 2:27 pm
OK this is good to hear - but let’s see what happens. we’re doing our bit to organise an e-petition to No. 10 as well.
May 11th, 2007 at 2:32 pm
It must be said that possibly the most shocking aspect of this whole fiasco has been the deafening silence of the Daily Star and its head honcho Mr Mahfuz Anam. Tasneem WORKS for the Daily Star, for godssake. It’s been 24 hours and still there has not been so much as a word on the front page of its website, not a link, not a line, not even a button to indicate that one of its more accomplished journalists has been kidnapped in the middle of the night. It was left to Zafar Sobhan to provide a brief comment for the international media. As for Mr Anam, who is probably the most prominent representative of that body that likes to call itself Shushil Shomaj (shushil my foot) - he has said nothing whatsoever in the last 24 hours.
How can anyone have any faith in such people’s integrity? How can anyone regard such people as our arbiters of moral authority? What a complete and utter disgrace! When the rubber hits the road, they’re quieter than a mouse. They would sooner abandon their own employees to the tender mercies of the security forces than say anything in protest. Why should anyone believe a word of Mr Anam’s when next he presumes to protest some injustice or the other, when everyone knows that he remained silent over the persecution of his own? The Daily Star and its chief editor has lost a LOT of respect over this disaster, and I doubt people will forget their silent acquiescence any time soon.
Tasneem, we hope you’re safe and that you’re released soon. But you’ll not be proud of the role of your own paper in all this.
May 11th, 2007 at 2:56 pm
Let’s wait and see. Who knows - the paper might be pursuing matters behind the scene ..
May 11th, 2007 at 3:01 pm
Iazuddin & Fakrhuddin at least can be honest and clear to their conscious. Iaz realized in Jan 11 and Fakr probably surely knows by now that they simply are puppets. They do not need to go against any one. They can simply refuse to serve as puppet and resign, or at least refuse to lies regarding who is in charge.
May 11th, 2007 at 3:03 pm
yeah Amit - credit to his wife indeed! - can you imagine - a woman’s worst nightmare - your husband being taken away by the army in the middle of the night. * our thoughts are with you!*
May 11th, 2007 at 3:07 pm
Mahfuz Anam is no coward and he is not afraid of military. When Army Chief gave a speech on democracy, the next day Mahfuz Anam brought out a special ‘commentary’ on the front page attacking the Chief. He is also not careless about his own employees.
The fact is : Tasneem has done something so wrong and Mahfuz Anam does not have an excuse to overrule that. Tomorrow, he will totally disown any report related to Tasneem Khalil. I guarantee it. Tasneem has not been detained for his writing. As a writer, he is not at all important. He has done some subversive activities which is punishable in any countries…even in those countries whose government officials are being pursued by some DP intellectuals !
May 11th, 2007 at 3:07 pm
[...] as I hear anything. Nothing is certain until he is released - the situation is quite fluid. Follow Drishtipat for up-to-the-minute [...]
May 11th, 2007 at 3:16 pm
re: daily star
it is indeed hard to believe the silence from the side of the daily star management, but please lets wait a while before jumping down mr. anam’s throat.
over the past years he (and his team) have consistently been by the side of the people. i want to wait to hear from the DS before judging them or losing respect. in my eyes, the military juncta is much more capable of threatening/intimidating citizens than we think.
-shahpar
May 11th, 2007 at 3:36 pm
It is perhaps not right to reach conclusions about Mahfuz Anam and Daily Star’s silence so quickly - it may be part of the deal that M. Anam had to agree to to ensure safe return of Tasneem… We should not forget that tacit diplomacy over expressive rebellion is often the better strategy to take.
May 11th, 2007 at 3:36 pm
bdnews24 has broken the silence. No signs of Daily Star speaking up as yet…
BREAKING NEWS
Joint forces lead away Daily Star journalist
Joint forces early Friday arrested a journalist who wrote about alleged human rights abuses during the rule of the army-backed caretaker government, his wife said. Tasneem Khalil, a journalist for The Daily Star, was picked up from his home by four officers in plainclothes, wife Sharmeen Afsana Suchi, told bdnews24.com by phone. “The joint forces didn’t show any arrest warrant. They said they don’t need any,” said Suchi who lives at her Central Road home in Dhanmondi.
May 11th, 2007 at 3:41 pm
no coverage from the BBC either. strange. you’d think they’d catch on to this story after their own alan johnston was kidnapped in gaza.
is any newspaper in BD covering this? what about the news channels?
-shahpar
May 11th, 2007 at 3:58 pm
Asaad, looks like Fakr has realised by now that he is riding on a royal Bengal tiger and is now afraid to get down. His government is making mess of everything rather than puting things in order. Whoever has in this wide world heard that the army has been able to put the pieces of a fractured democracy together? It’s all crazy!! They always make a mess of everything.
May 11th, 2007 at 4:14 pm
“In a statement, The Daily Star Editor Mahfuz Anam said: “I contacted the authorities concerned and was informed that him being questioned was not due to his journalistic work and had nothing to do with his functions at The Daily Star.”
but dear Mahfuz bhai, did you think they would say otherwise? Did you think they would say, we picked him up because he is a “fearless” journalist…?
May 11th, 2007 at 4:14 pm
Each second is passing like a year!
The Daily Star has two options: if the behind the scene dealings (if any) go wrong, they might finally speak up. But the funny thing would be, freeing Tasneem by agreeing to the acquisition of army. But for those who know the truth, it doesn’t matter. All we want is a Free Tasneem. Then, we can carry on our pen and finger with the truth.
May 11th, 2007 at 4:20 pm
OK guys….time to face the reality. Mahfuz Anam has just released a statement to UNB stating that Tasneem Khalil has been arrested NOT for his journalism, but for his other personal activities. Check this out with UNB or any newspaper editor.
May 11th, 2007 at 4:22 pm
ok i’m about to steal some of the wording of your text in the DP petition to turn into an e-petition to ol’ Tony before he runs of. Is that ok with you guys??
cheers
sonia
May 11th, 2007 at 4:27 pm
I think we should all write to the BBC Correspondent in dhaka asking why they’re not covering the story/
May 11th, 2007 at 4:35 pm
i would like to take this opportunity to thank all the people who stand beside us, Tasneems family.i have to admit im not that involved in media so i leave it to you people to mobilize a movment to free my brother. we are trying to find out his whereabouts by contacting the relevent officials.But if any of you any idea about any course of action that can be taken from the u.k where i reside, please contact m on my mobile +4407957135222 or write to me at mirage_u_c@hotmail.com
May 11th, 2007 at 4:35 pm
Finally BBC covered this story:
May 11th, 2007 at 4:41 pm
[...] Tasneem Khailil,Drishtipat 上也有給孟加拉政府的連署信。 « Dreaming Lhasa and Exile [...]
May 11th, 2007 at 4:41 pm
Process is this:
1. ‘Guilty’
2. Target, select & cook accusation
2. Grab at midnight
3. Arrest and wait to see reaction
4. If favorable, accuse, if not, release with trauma.
May 11th, 2007 at 4:43 pm
I have always been proud of working at the Daily Star and have great respect for MA. I really hope this apparent indifference about Tasneem is actually helping Tasneem in some way. Unfortunately, it was a holiday for me so I really don’t know what the mood at the office is. But it’s 10:30pm now and I am not hearing anything about his release yet. Tasneem has been one of the very few outspoken voices against the present government. We disappointingly did not get the same outspoken reactions from any of the higher ups at DS (and yes I do mean MA as well). But this will really be the last straw…
May 11th, 2007 at 4:46 pm
and still they got his name wrong on the BBC story - TaNSeem Khalil!
May 11th, 2007 at 4:52 pm
BBC Bengali (probaho) covered the news of his arrest this evening (BST)
http://www.bbc.co.uk/mediaselector/check/bengali/meta/tx/beng_probaho?size=au&bgc=003399&lang=bn&nbram=1&nbwm=1
However, nothing on the front-page though.
This is an absolute outrage! Then again to have expected any thing better from a military regime would be foolhardy indeed!
FREE TASNEEM!
LG
May 11th, 2007 at 5:12 pm
Mr./Ms. ABC wrote:
“The fact is : Tasneem has done something so wrong and Mahfuz Anam does not have an excuse to overrule that.”
You seem to know something that we don’t, unless what you wrote is mere supposition/speculation. Can you kindly enlighten us about the “fact” ?
May 11th, 2007 at 5:13 pm
ABC wrote
UPDATE : The overwhelming empathy for Tasneem Khalil is remarkable. I, however, have got an update from Joint Forces. Tasneem Khalil has NOT been detained for his ‘fearless’ journalism. He has been identified as an individual who was spreading a seditious SMS, a campaign against military in the last few weeks. After a series of investigation about the chain of SMSs, it has been found that Tasneem was the originator. JF decided to know the motive behind such campaign and when asked him today, he confessed and said
he was doing it just to get ‘fame’. His boss Mahfuz Anam went to meet the senior JF officials this morning and when Tasneem’s SMS and proofs of other anti-law activities were shown to him, he just escaped declaring his ignorance about those. Mahfuz Anam found it ‘very immatured’ about what Tasneem was doing in the past few days. Tasneem’s confession, apology and promise of not doing any subversive activities in the future are on tape. Let us not jump on the conclusion whenever you see something you don’t want to see. There could be different explanation which you are not aware of.
To which Rahnuma replied:
How on earth could I have been so stupid!! And here I was thinking it was for his articles on Modhupur eco-park, on RAB crossfire deaths and torture, on the intelligence agencies acting as an in-between for Tareque Zia and Khatme Nabuwwat, JMB etc. etc. Thank you so much for enlightening me, so kind of you. Hey, but why was the Forum issue withdrawn?
Sorry but this story just won’t sell, i can see you guys are trying real hard, but please credit us with with more intelligence.
May 11th, 2007 at 5:21 pm
Just out: He has been released.
May 11th, 2007 at 5:24 pm
He’s just been released. He is currently at the Daily Star office.
May 11th, 2007 at 5:29 pm
ABC Can you please tell who you are.
and are you chief Justice of the country
that you are going to give the judgement that
with anti national activities. I think spy like
ISI and all are doing such thing. Fact that Mafuz Anam did not appoint you as your PS that you ill speak on behalf of him. we undersdtand it is huge violation of human right.
May 11th, 2007 at 5:34 pm
When Rubel was tortured and killed, AC Akram told that he was a criminal. When Muntasir Mamun and Saber Chow was arrested, the govt claimed that they have linked with Mymensingh bomb blast. So I’m not surprised that the govt is coming up with controversy theory against Tasneem.
What surprises me is Mahfuz Anam’s stand. His statement claims that Tasneem was arrested for some other allegation other than journalistic reason. So Mr. Anam, why were u so vocal about a local journalist Tipu but so silent about one of ur brightest employees ?
May 11th, 2007 at 5:44 pm
A day with high drama ends. Some people have worked vocally, some have done behind the scene.Thank you all. You know who you are. A few points to make:
1. Don’t make sweeping judgements without knowing all the facts. Whatever editorial decisions we have taken over the last 24 hours was aimed at one goal — release of Tasneem and mobilization of efforts that was going on.
2. There will be an attempt to dig up dirt on Tasneem from tonight onwards. I predict an Amadershomoy article on his “suspicious activities”. Our country is never short of yellow journalist when you want them.
3. However, I hope Daily Star and Mahfuz Anam can take a principled stand on this — which is if Tasneem has committed a crime, he should be tried in proper court of law. But not by midnight raid and without due process. His freedom to write should be protected by all means.
4. This is exactly why all our bloggers and other dp writers, have been stressing on due process for all including people whom we do not like. There is no inconsistency there. If you allow unfair means for one, it is only a matter of time before they apply the same method for someone whom you like. No one is more equal than others.
In Solidarity
May 11th, 2007 at 5:46 pm
[...] Khalil has now been released. Worryingly, his detention was apparently “not due to his journalistic work and had nothing [...]
May 11th, 2007 at 5:54 pm
Even if SMS was done, so what! Government must be able to cope with malicious criticism, truth or not. If content has truth, great, not, he loses weight. SMS could have been from raw.
May 11th, 2007 at 5:57 pm
[...] Star journalist, CNN stringer and Blogger Tasneem Khalil was taken into military custody yesterday. Drishtipat has updates on the [...]
May 11th, 2007 at 6:01 pm
Has anyone read Mahfuz Anam’s statement on Bdnews? Man, what a cop out!
May 11th, 2007 at 6:02 pm
Anyway, a wise decision to release him. I dont think the army realized that a single arrest of a petty journalist will create so much hue in the international community as well as online blogs. They were compelled to release him.
But will the govt learn from their mistake ? I guess not, govts never do especially when the army is given so much power. We’ll see similar incidents in future.
May 11th, 2007 at 6:07 pm
Is Tasneem free to blog again?
If the army arrested him for blogging as Mahfuz Anam’s statement says — is there a precedence of this in any part of the world?
And the CA talks about reforms? Shame.
We should pursue this until there is a personal apology to Mr. Khalil from the Caretaker government.
This is way too much.
May 11th, 2007 at 6:15 pm
It’s is good to see an outpouring of support for Tanseem Khalil but my question is how many of us know him personally?
Mr. Khalil good journalist and blog author, of which I am also a fan.
But as stated in the Daily Star press release Mr. Khalil was arrested for circulatiing SMSs which allegedly border on anti state activity.
In his blogs he proudly claimed to have sources within the government(army).
The law enforcement agencies have the right and duty to detain and question any person who engages in allegedly questionable activities againts the state, specially during an emergency.
May 11th, 2007 at 6:19 pm
Hasib,
From Wiki:
Political dangers
Blogging can sometimes have unforeseen consequences in politically sensitive areas.
In Singapore, two ethnic Chinese were imprisoned under the country’s anti-sedition law for posting anti-Muslim remarks in their weblogs.[40]
Egyptian blogger Kareem Amer was charged of insulting the Egyptian president Hosni Mubarak and an Islamic institution through his online blog. It is the first time in the history of Egypt that a blogger was prosecuted. After a brief trial session that took place in Alexandria, the blogger was found guilty and sentenced to prison terms of three years for insulting Islam and inciting sedition, and one year for insulting Mubarak.[41]
After expressing opinions in his personal weblog about the state of the Sudanese armed forces, Jan Pronk, United Nations Special Representative for the Sudan, was given three days notice to leave Sudan. The Sudanese army had demanded his deportation
May 11th, 2007 at 6:29 pm
Ref :103
Boishakhi
It is not the matter of knowing Tasneem.
It is the matter of Credibility. At least
I don’t find any thing wrong in his blog.
If any Extra Judicial things like Modhupur took place he has right to make report.
Our point is due process. Govt does not have any right to take any one at mid night from his home.
May 11th, 2007 at 6:33 pm
Adding to Asif S’s comments above. It’s excellent news that he has been released!
But this episode should leave less doubt about…
1. Military, specifically DGFI, is running the show, not Fakr. The civilian administration had no clue this was going on until contacted by the media. ABC, wouldnt you agree?
2. Intimidation outside the law is the main tactic they’re following. “Let’s get Tasneem for spilling the beans on DGFI/Tariq/Extremist connection, and that should be a deterrent to the anyone who wants to investigate us.” Same tactic as with victimizing some politicians to warn others.
3. They would NOT have released Tasneem so quickly without such a great amount of media pressure so quickly. (Thank you!)
4. They know they’re being watched. We should not become less vigilant just ’cause Tasneem has been released; we should become more.
May 11th, 2007 at 6:49 pm
http://www.amadershomoy.com/news.php?id=162379&sys=3
May 11th, 2007 at 7:12 pm
Dear ABC and anybody with the same background…
First let me be clear about our intentions…
1. Lets not discuss from WE and THEY point of view. I believe and I know you also believe deep inside that we are all bonded with one same blood.. The blood of one family called Bangladesh.
2. We are all “US”. And our goal is a better, livable, peaceful prosperous Bangladesh. May be as member of police/defence force you are doing your job and me as a NRB professional I am doing my job. But at the end of the day we all have the same passion, and same interest.
3. When we have the same interest, we definitely can and should discuss, not debate or quarrel. Discussion should include candid expressions of your feelings about us and at the same time we also should share our discomfort about you.
4. Believe me an open discussion will make us friends, not enemies.
5. That’s why, you have noticed that your comments are not moderated in this blog.
6. We want to hear from you and know about your concerns.
7. There has long been a big communication gap between smart young defence professionas and the other professionals. Let this DP blog be the staging ground for the first flag meeting.
8. Lets friendship, understanding, patriotism and nationalism prevail. We have so mnay problems in BD, we simply can’t afford to use our energy in internal fightings.
May 11th, 2007 at 7:24 pm
Boishakhi,
Even sedition charges have to follow due process. Otherwise they become an all-purpose tool to silence dissent.
XYZ,
Does the entire “show” consist of picking up journalists and intimidating the press? Such blanket statements do not help anyone or provide any insight. What the incident shows is that there are several “shows” in town, each being run by its own circus-master. Unfortunately, the government should be the only show in town!
Rumi,
Excellently put. Simply excellent.
May 11th, 2007 at 7:28 pm
boishakhi:
I do not personally agree with some of the things Mr. Khalil has wrote in his posts.
In fact, he has made some very disparaging remarks about Dr. Yunus and those who supported him when he announced he is entering politcs.
I am quoting from his site under the post - Sibyl, Army and Yunus :
>>Just to add sauce to the dish, after a few weeks, the self-proclaimed “banker to the poor” appeared on the political stage with that wide-open grin, bare teeth. And waged a war on the “corrupt and backward culture of politics” in Bangladesh. As if the promised messiah had arrived well before we saw Dajjal’s donkey, thousands of his admirers instantly started clapping like monkeys.
May 11th, 2007 at 7:41 pm
If the net effect of this episode is to silence critics of the government and the military, then the people behind this arrest may have accomplished their goal. This will have a chilling effect on the rest of the journalists. In this case, Mr. Khalil had the good fortune of being well known outside Bangladesh and the authorities felt the pressure. But this may not be the case for other lesser known journalists.
The greater point that needs to be made is that if the CTG is honestly interested in feeling the pulse of the people, it cannot be seen to intimidate journalists, whether it intends to or not. If there are charges unrelated to journalism against Tasneem Khalil or any one else, as some have referred to, these need to be pursued through a due process. And due process does not include raiding one’s home in the middle of the night and taking him away without an arrest warrant.
For one thing, I don’t understand statements that a reporter circulating SMS constitutes anti-state activity. Reporters have sources everywhere and they have to be in touch with those sources. That’s part of their job.
The government advisers have consistently maintained that the press is free to do its job, even in the state of emergency. One cannot claim to have a free press and at the same time enforce punitive emergency measures against journalists.
May 11th, 2007 at 7:53 pm
Have you seen this news: Police killed two innocent brothers, along with 4 other alleged criminals, at Banaripara, Barisal?
http://www.shamokal.com/details.php?nid=60675
May 11th, 2007 at 8:00 pm
#105 Tannoy don’t get me wrong, by knowing him personally what I meant to say was that we know about Mr. Khalil only as much as he chooses to “publish” about himself i.e. his role at Daily Star, being a blogger and his affilation with CNN etc. He is still a very junior journalist in Bangladesh and thus we have very little independent background information on him.
Many newspapers in Bangladesh have written articles expressing concerns about extra judicial killings in Bangladesh but as far as I know none have been detained or jailed so far although some may have been questioned. So writing about Modhupur killings may not be the reason behind his detention.
You may recall that a New York Times correspondant, Judith Miller, recently served jailed term and was fired by NYT for not disclosing her source for outing a CIA agent. In other words the US government wanted to find out who was leaking sensitive government information to the media.
You talk about due process, well to this what I want to say is that either you agree with the current state of Emergency or you don’t. If you don’t then any argument I present to you will be pointless but if you do then you must agree that under emergency law the joint forces have the power to detain anyone without due process.
Besides that, after the atrocities of 9/11 many western governments regularly pickup terrorist suspects and can hold them in custody without trial. In Britain a suspect can be held and not charged with anything for upto 28 days and there is strong lobbying from the British police to have this extended to 90 days.
There are people in Gitmo who have been held for years without trial and we all know about the internment of terrorist suspects by the CIA.
I am not trying to pass a judgement on Mr. Khalil, I don’t know the man. But I would protest if he was detained for his journalistice work. But at this point we can only speculate as to the reasons behind his detention but I am afraid it will be just another he said she said and we are unlikely to find out the truth.
May 11th, 2007 at 8:13 pm
I just wanted to mention that like many of you I did send an email to bdnews24 yesterday urging them to publish the story about Mr. Khalil’s detention and expressing my concerns.
May 11th, 2007 at 8:13 pm
[...] After outrage erupted in the blogosphere (and in some cases the media, including the Human Rights Watch) it seems that the Bangladesh government has released Tasneem according to Unheard Voices. [...]
May 11th, 2007 at 9:24 pm
it’s time for the CTG to start plans for holding elections ASAP and not 18 months later. this sham of a government with utter disregard for due process and the rule of law has to stop.
May 11th, 2007 at 9:30 pm
Boishakhi,
Apnar concerns khub valid ebong ami khub seriously nichchi. You’ll find it mentioned in the DP petition that “if there are no charges against him”, then he should be released. Are you convinced that the forces had anything more than a suspicion?
Yes, emergency means that fundamental rights are suspended. But if the emergency is to work in the short term, then people both inside and outside the government must be highly vigilant that abuse of detention powers do not occur. It has almost certainly occurred in this case. In the long term, very few “emergencies” last without conceding fundamental rights. I have already mentione the arrest of bloggers in Egypt, which has been under emergency laws since 1980 if I’m not mistaken.
The comparisons with the US are somwhat misleading. Aren’t all Bangladeshis unanimous in condemning Gitmo? Why, ask our ABC brother what he thinks of it and he’ll assure you that the US is a human rights violator. No one’s saying anything to the contrary. But do we want to be like the U.S.? Don’t we want to be ourselves, much better than the U.S. hopefully?
The comparison with Judith Miller is somewhat misleading. If you remember, her source was apparently Libby who outed a CIA agent. If anything the abuse of power was against the outed-CIA agent. It wasn’t the CIA agent leaking to the press and the press member getting arrested. It was an executive branch official, leaking ABOUT the CIA agent, and the press trying to cover up. Laws were actually broken. I don’t know of a single law in Bangladesh that TK’s reports have broken. But then again, it is am emergency, you might be breaking the law if you’re walking down the street and looking at people funny! Jokes aside, if members of our armed forces face abuses like that against Plame at the hands of those in power (whether military or civilian), I will be the first one to condemn it.
May 11th, 2007 at 9:56 pm
ABC,
I am convinced that you are a military personnel.
However, being a military personnel, are you authorised to leak out the internal matters and actions by the JF? Did you take permission from your controlling officer before sending your comments to the blogsphere? Aren’t you aware that as per the goverment’s secrecy act such actions are strictly prohibited?
If Tasneem Khalil,( a private citizen journalist, human rights activist) can be detained for his blogs and sms, then what action should be taken against a military personal (or a government servant) for leaking out news in advance in different blogspere regarding government activities?
What if someone records your IP address? What if some day some agency investigates into it? What if ‘necessary action’ is taken against the personell for his or her misconduct?
May 11th, 2007 at 10:30 pm
# Joy Says:
>it’s time for the CTG to start plans for holding >elections ASAP and not 18 months later. this sham >of a government with utter disregard for due >process and the rule of law has to stop.
Let’s keep things in perspective. Our past two elected governments did not quite present us with models of due process, to say the least. So, lack of due process does not present itself as a compelling reason to return to elected government in a hurry.
I do agree that with some degree of reforms, democracy can and will perform better than it has. But, the key word is reform.
Unfortunately, with a number of mis-steps, this government has weakened its credibility and only
boosted the power of those who will do politics as usual when they are returned to power. The prospect of meaningful reform has gone down considerably.
May 11th, 2007 at 10:59 pm
ABC wrote about Tasneem Khalil: ‘He has been identified as an individual who was spreading a seditious SMS, a campaign against military in the last few weeks.’
Oh, so you can’t say anything against the military, and if you do so, you will be detained? By which law, ABC?
You detain a young journalist just for sending SMS? The military doesn’t have any other work to do? SMS dhorar jonno jonogoner eto poisha khoroch kore oder posha hoi? SMS khoja ether ‘Protirokkha’r kaaj? Do the rules of business of the ministry of defence say that this is their job?
I’ve heard that there is an agency in Bangladesh called ‘military intelligence’. What an irony! The word ‘intelligence’ does not go with ‘military’… ha ha ha..:D
May 11th, 2007 at 10:59 pm
Joy, re #116,
“Elections” did not fix “due process” in last 15 years, what makes you think elections alone will fix it, “ASAP” like a magic wand?
May 11th, 2007 at 11:00 pm
AsifY,
I agree with your analysis but also stand by my comments.
We must not forget how the emergency came about, it is not that the army was eagerly waiting for an opportunity to grab power. Emergency was declared as a last resort due to the actions of BNP and AL.
The army as an institution is trained to fight wars and not govern a country. They will make mistakes and people like you and me, the general public, must point out these mistakes and allow the CTG+army to take corrective measures. So far the interim government has backed down on many issues such as evicting slum dwellers, Allowing Hasina to return, lifting ban on media etc.
The point I was trying to make with the Judith Miller example is that being a journalist does not give one immunity to protect their sources. If the Joint Forces beleive that someone from within the army or CTG is leaking information to Mr. Khalil, he can compelled to reveal his source.
After Mr. Khalil was detained many of you have urged fellow blog participants to get in touch with law makers in the US and UK. But what I wanted to point out is that these very countries lock up people indefinately without trial in Belmarsh and Gitmo on the ground of national security.
In both UK and US the indefinite detention issue has been contested at the highest courts but the courts have not declared the detentions illegal.
Surely I hope there comes a day when Bangladesh can be a model for other “older” democracies like US and the UK but until that day comes we must for now settle for holding a free and fair election without muscle power, black money and corruption.
The armed forces must be given the time and space to arrange this free and fair election so they don’t have to take the burden of declaring another emergency in couple of years time.
May 11th, 2007 at 11:13 pm
Boishakhi said: “The armed forces must be given the time and space to arrange this free and fair election so they don’t have to take the burden of declaring another emergency in couple of years time.”
Sorry, this is not the job of the armed forces to ‘arrange free and fair election’. This is the job of the Caretaker government. The election commission is there to assist the government in this regard. A free and fair election has never ever been ‘arranged’ by any military government in our country since its independence.
May 11th, 2007 at 11:43 pm
Its been a long day. I know that things are calming down since the tail end of the comments have reverted back to the pros and cons of this military government. I’d have to say that we just had a small taste of the cons.
May 12th, 2007 at 12:44 am
Boishakhi,
Then we are in almost complete agreement. If you’ve read my other comments on DP or on my blog, you would have seen that nowhere do I lay the cause of this current emergency on the Army. I am sick and tired of our two major parties (I never gave the third one any credit!).
I have nothing but the highest regard for our armed forces. Without them, we would not have enjoyed 36 long years of freedom from foreign domination. But as you point out, they are not trained to be rulers or policy-makers. Neither are they trained to be judge or jury. When they make mistakes like this, we have to point it out which we did. But aren’t we oversimplifying just a bit? Weren’t we told the other day that it’s the CTG who is in control? If the advisors are not trained to run the country, who is? If the advisors are not in charge, who is? You can’t ask for transparency without being transparent yourself. In this regard, see the example of Brig. (Retd.) Sakhawat of the EC, who on his appointment disclosed his entire financial history for the public to scrutinise. This man is now in a position to ask politicians for transparency now that he has done it himself.
On principle, I do not like appealing to “Western” or foreign powers any more than you do. Not because they are “hypocrites” (all countries are when it comes to international affairs), but because I do not like non-citizens interfering with our domestic issues. However, we all make pragmatic compromises. Especially when we feel that someone’s life must be in danger. Cop out?:)
Why was this compromise necessary? Because we do not have any working institution where an ordinary citizen might ask for protection against the powers that be. The day we have institutions that do that consistently (I’m willing to settle for 80% of all cases at the moment, though there is no way to measure), is the day I will feel like I don’t have to appeal to foreigners to safeguard my rights as a citizen.
“The armed forces must be given the time and space to arrange this free and fair election so they don’t have to take the burden of declaring another emergency in couple of years time.” - I couldn’t agree with you more. If you look at Tasneem’s last entry, this is basically the point I was trying to make in his comments section. My defence of Tasneem does not in any way indicate total agreement with everything he says, but my commitment to his right to say it. As I’ve said, I’d hate to see a return to the status quo ante: two rudderless, policy-less parties claiming to be of, by, for the people, but in reality being of, by and for themselves only. For once I’d like to see unanimous agreement in parliament on something other than raising their own salaries.
May 12th, 2007 at 12:51 am
I think Asif S’ [#97] and Rumi [#108] has articulated the real picture of the game very well. The most significant achievement of today’s blogging is not a free-Tasneem, it’s the ABC’s contribution to the blog.
I do not buy all the points made by “ABC”, but I respect this intelligent way of confrontation. Such brainy interactions can help us avoid using the “other means” of disagreement/protest.
We should always welcome the other side to contribute their rational thoughts so that we can make our points heard. “ABC”, either being a person or being a group, has made the right decision by updating us regularly with the other part of the logic. I look forward to the continuation of such brainy interactions.
May 12th, 2007 at 3:04 am
TK is the only local journo listed as a researcher in HRW’s in-depth report last year on RAB: “Judge Jury & Executioner”
So, Boishakhi, he does indeed stand out as separate from all others, as a special target for recrimination, who have written about this.
May 12th, 2007 at 3:55 am
RE: #123 anon
Bangladesh is not currently under a Caretaker Government as prescribed in the constituion. Although we (including myself) keep using the term CTG in our posts in reality we currently have a Military backed non-party emergency interim government. CTG only has a mandate to hold a free and fair election within 90 days.
– You say “A free and fair election has never ever been ‘arranged’ by any military government in our country since its independence.” –
Well we are yet to have a truly democratic government in Bangladesh since independece, so maybe it’s time we try a different approach. The EC will surely conduct the election but under the watchful eye of the military.
The military was deployed to ensure law and order in all elections after the fall of Ershad. This time around they will be tasked with preparing voter ID for all eligible voters and also to maintain law and order on election day.
In any country it is the duty of the law enforcement agencies to maintain law and order, cabinet ministers (members of the CTG) are usually not involved with their day to day activities. Under the current state of emergency it is the duty of the Joint forces to maintain law and order, make arrests, detain people, file cases etc.
The law minister (law adviser) formulates policies and guidelines and is not involved with field work. So the members of the CTG are running the government but law enforcement is the duty of the joint forces which is led by the army. You don’t expect Mr. Fakhruddin or Mainul Hossain to run around and arrest people, do you?
May 12th, 2007 at 5:44 am
DGFI General Rumi who was in the post for the last 5 years during the BNP years and known for his BNP affiliation has been transferred to a much less important Ansar/VDP role.
http://www.amadershomoy.com/news.php?id=162380&sys=3
May 12th, 2007 at 8:35 am
Rumi, #109, Shuvro # 127 : Thanks for your passionate and logical reasoning. It makes sense. My postings were not moderated by DP, but detained for about 4 hours ! As DP was not releasing those, I had to look around in other blogs to send the message across.
There was nothing malicious in my posts. I was trying to reveal the real facts. I came under heavy attack - very derogatory remarks and what not. My point was : we need to think that there could be other reasons. We love to go to foreigners for problems of our bedroom ! Anytime anything happens, we must get the foreign ambassadors, senators, UN…..every possible outsiders.
One can think little rationally - is our army creating any ban on the freedom of speech ? Has there been any reference ? NO. Rather, army was unusually tolerant and forbearing. The media is writing openly..everyday. They didn’t spare even the army chief who made some remarks on politics. Media is too powerful…at least they are allowed to be (under the state of emergency).
Tasneem Khalil is not a world famous journalist. His reports don’t count if you take hundreds of critical reports everyday. Why should he be detained for his so called ‘fearless’ writing ? And if it was so, why would Mahfuz Anam, the rebellious media figure would stay away clean from this ? Does it require too much intellects to grasp ?
Behind his fearless writing and human rights activities, Tasneem was doing something which you don’t want to know/believe. I will share it later on when time comes.
Lastly, the drama is not over yet. In fact, this drama can become a Holywood blockbuster movie if you see the entire script, as plotted by Tasneem so dilligently. Thanks in advance for your patience……
May 12th, 2007 at 12:20 pm
ABC I think You should know If any Crime is done in Bedroom, It should be informed.
Now I think you don’t have any Idea of the
freedom of press. Still Now Today We don’t know what is the Charge behind Janakantha Editor Atiullah Khan Masud?
You mentioned Tasneem is not a famous Journalist but You same people are Scared of his writting.
And again Please don’t try to misguide the people . We have also read Mahfuz Anam’s statement. He simply translated the speech of Army. Rather He speaks about the commitment of the CTG regarding freedom of speech. So To make Mafuz Anam Party is not a very good motive.
Because He did not write any thing against Tasneem But he might take bold step as they
all were so Vocal about Tipu Sultan.
Just I am surprised to thik is DGFI and Army so weak that they need to Pick up a 26 years young Kid at midnight.
Rather I think You are playing a big Drama giving some spicy story of the Behind ABC.
[On hold]
May 12th, 2007 at 1:19 pm
ABC:
Whats stopping you from publishing the full Hollywood script right now? We cannot wait any longer in suspense.. Hahaha. I dont know what to tell you man.
May 12th, 2007 at 4:49 pm
ABC, activists are not the only ones who interact with “foreigners” on domestic issues.
i) The Bangladesh Army’s #1 source of work, revenue, result and pride (and I use all of these terms sincerely, not sarcastically) has been the Army’s role as #1 provider of troops to UN Peacekeeping.
ii) The key factor for Jan 11 was UN’s declaration on Jan 10 that if Army certified fraudulent elections, they would lose peacekeeping role.
iii) Foreign Affais advisor Iftakhar C was picked because he was crucial in advocating BD for leading role in UN operation.
iv) Gen Moeen was crucial person in UN overseas operation
v) Current CTG has taken many steps to make sure diplomatic missions and overseas govts do not put pressure on quick elections
vi) Faruq Sobhan was sent on mission to US to try to build good image of CTG’s mission
vii) CTG has signed (or is making moves to sign) new partnership agreements w/ Burma
viii) Gen Moeen was supposed to visit India, although that seems to have been postponed for now
ix) CTG has had talks about strengthening relations w/ Pakistan (papers report)
So everyone interacts with “foreign powers”.
HR activists are the only ones that called “enemy of the state”. Isn’t that convenient?
May 12th, 2007 at 4:52 pm
This week in USA, two young businessmen were sent to jail for 3 months because they were setting up a prank joke.
Their “joke” was that they wired-up the main streets of the town in strategic areas, to make it look like a terrorist bomb setup.
In court they said they didnt want to cause anybody any concern, didnt know it would be a security panic, and it was just a joke.
Often people do things which they believe are either harmless or beneficial to society, but unknowingly could be MAJOR THREATS to public.
Per ABC #131, Tasneem may have been involved in such activity, without his knowledge of their apparent national risks. To me, thats exactly what this entire story of TK reads.
May 12th, 2007 at 5:15 pm
Joshim #134, “interaction” with foreign govts is not the issue, what you are listing are foreign relations activities, necessary to maintain trade and diplomatic relations.
The issue of concern is hanging dirty laundry with foreign orgs, in order to get their support. We all know foreign “powers” are only for their OWN interest - see Iraq, and even in dirty laundry they will only FIND their own interest!
Example, during BNP rule, some Opposition members were lobbying to these powers, that “Bangladesh is an Al-Qaeda nation”, not long after 9/11. Sure the lobbyists had “good intentions” - but the negative propaganda could potentially lead BD to another “WMD” target!
When foreign powers are approached with dirty laundry, they find these lobbyists at their own mercy, meaning they find weakness in the nation which they can EXPLOIT. Foreigners then manipulate the weakness, using HR and WMD excuses and “concerns” and extrapolate thier own SHARE of the benefits.
In the case of TK, if there was any subversive activity going on (security issues), without our knowledge, then even asking the foreign powers’ help would not make any diffrence. It would just be pure dirty laundry!
May 12th, 2007 at 5:31 pm
Joshim,
Points well-taken. Interactions with foreign government is a function of any government. Diplomatic Missions are meant for that. Promoting friendship, trade and other multilateral issues are one thing and ‘complaining’ about own domestic problems are quite different. Anyways, the debate could be quite long on this issue. But that was not what I tried to highlight. Let us not get drifted. I was encouraged by few bloggers and thought of clarifying my position in my last posting.
Military knows very well who writes what and what has been discussed in the last 3 months. Very open discussions, critical analyses, criticisms, points/counterpoints. Military believes on freedom of speech and individual rights. At times, very objectionable remarks are also made against military. Those are viewed as ‘personal opinions’ and never interfered. May be some of you are thinking that you are indulging in your intellectual efforts sitting in a different country (a safe place)and you are beyond reach. Very wrong. If military wants to get you, it will get you. In fact, you will struggle on your own to catch the next available flight to Dhaka. But military is not interested on you….or any particular blogger. You have 100% freedom of expressing your views and you are already enjoying it uninterruptedly.
Blogging and sending SMS is no crime (as many has asked this question). In fact blogging and SMSs are the wonders of modern science in effective communication. As long as you use your knife to cut potatoes, you are fine. Try this on cutting somebody’s throat, you are in big trouble.
So you don’t know the content of Tasneem’s SMSs. You don’t know what was found in his computer. You don’t know who else were his contacts apart from you guys. It is obvious, you will scream. Ever seen in movie an FBI action ? Ever heard the term counter-terrorism? Think about the entire thing in cool brain.
Six JMB men were executed few days ago. Did they all kill anyone personally ? Did they detonate any bomb? All they did was ‘talking’ to their friends/followers. Is ‘talking’ illegal (some might ask)?
Let me finish here and I will return in few days with the ’script’ ! Enjoy your blogging. Say whatever you want to. Criticize or advise any way you want. Nobody will tell you (or your family members back home) anything. You should all be proud that your military has got respect, appreciation and love in over 2 dozens countries for their professional work. They are not aliens from Mars. They are your brothers, uncles and nephews. They are not against you and they have no interest in stopping your right to speak freely.
Mr. Tanoy, you would do great if you get active in any Bangla blog
May 12th, 2007 at 6:14 pm
ABC
I hope you appreciate the freedom of expression and speech you are enjoying in different blogs. And I believe spending a bit more time in this environment will help you develop more tolerance to contradicting thoughts, theories, blogs and SMSs.
I do welcome and appreciate your sincere participation and I don’t have the slightest doubt about your love and efforts for Bangladesh.
However I am a little disappointed at your comments elsewhere with undisguised threats to the bloggers and their families.
I am a little puzzled too. How can we communicate constructively if you start resorting to threatening words so early in the discussion?
This makes me believe that although you are the one who is flexing the muscle here and there every now and then and threatening people randomly, you are the most scared among all of us present here.
Look at me first, I have no hesitation to reveal who I am, what I do for living. I am Rumi Ahmed, a physician and an assistant professor at a medical college in a US Midwestern university and I am not timid enough to hide myself under a pseudonym. Not only me, almost all the primary bloggers and commentators are daring write with their own name. The other guy who writes blog here is Asif. He is a vice president of the top Wall Street investment bank. You are showing that you are far more scared to hide your name, e mail address or profession. Do you know what that means? It means you may also be an imposter, or just faking to be an inportant and informed man or what you ar doing is not permitted by Bangladesh governmnet or military rules. Or may be ( I like to believe it) you actually are a spokesperson for the joint forces.
To continue a meaningful conversation, it is very important that we know each other. Otherwise it cease to be a conversation, it turns into a hide and seek game.
May 12th, 2007 at 6:34 pm
Achcha ABC bhai,
Jodi shotti amader freedom of speech apnar kachey bhaalo laagey, taholey eto threats keno? Eto raag keno apnar je amra amader shei freedom bebohar korchi?
Tasneemer bepaarey jodi shotti kichu jene thaakten, taholey arrester shomoy bollen na keno? Ekta judge ke evidence dekhay ekta warrant jogar korlen na keno? Ei shob proshner uttor den, shudhu amader pride ar respect for the army’r jonno kotha boilen na. Ei page e koy jone asey je army ke galaisey? Of course, army te amader baap-chacha, bhai or bonera aasey. Shei jonnoi to amra jaani je amader army te shudhu apnar moto crude ebong dui-mukhi manush bhorti na. “We can get you if we want” - no sir. You can get us if you can prove that we have done something wrong. Ar shonen bhai, bar bar FBI tanben na. Onno ra bhul korley ki ap