Formalin Scare: Some Perspectives
In the recent news, the use of formalin by the dealers/transporters/shop owners in the Bangladeshi fish market has raised lot of concern, genuinely so, because Banglee’s ever lasting fondness for fish is well known. Hence the saying Machhe Bhate Bangalee. It’s time we have some perspectives on the issue of formalin use in fish.
First of all ‘what is formalin?’. To most of us it is the smell of the air when you enter any hospital/clinic in BD. Formalin is actually a generic term which describes a solution of 37% formaldehyde gas dissolved in water. [Formaldehyde is produced by adding oxygen to methyl alcohol – the first product in the fermentation process and also a common disinfectant, known as rubbing alcohol in U.S.]
Formalin is used to store biological specimens in laboratories, even preserving human bodies in medical profession known as embalm to prevent the tissues from natural decomposition. Formalin does that by irreversibly binding the protein in the cells with the DNA. But this can lead to deadly effect on living bodies in uncontrolled environment and if used in excess quantity.
Because formalin is readily soluble in water, if consumed it quickly transforms to formic acid (the same thing found in ant bites), which raises the acidity in blood leading to conditions like rapid, shallow breathing, blurred vision or complete blindness, hypothermia, and, in the most severe cases, coma or death. People who accidentally ingest large amount of formalin should seek immediate medical help. Formalin tested on laboratory animals have shown to have carcinogenic (cancer causing) effect. On lighter side formalin can have allergic effect on people. It can cause moderate to severe skin rash and itching.
The use of formalin to prevent fish parasites is not entirely uncommon, but it has to be done in a very controlled way to prevent the toxic effect it might produce. Solutions of formalin for use on fish should contain 10 to 15% methyl alcohol, which inhibits formation of paraformaldehyde a highly toxic compound. In USA only two kinds of commercial products have the approval of Food and Drug Administration (FDA) to be used on selected species of fishes. And even then, the products (not raw formalin) are used to give the fishes a ‘bath’ – meaning apply the formalin product on the fishes for few minutes and then transfer them to a container filled with fresh water to rinse off the excess of formalin.
These controlled products are effective on parasites only, not bacterial or fungal infections. The temperature control is another huge factor when using formalin product (not raw formalin) for fish, because if the temperature is below 40 degree Fahrenheit (5 degree Celcius) then the toxic compound paraformaldehyde will be formed that has deadlier effect than formalin alone. The toxicity is also known to increase at a temperature higher than 75 F (21 C). That is scary because in Bangladesh the temperature is almost always above that level.
It is conceivable that none of the measures discussed above are being taken by the fish dealers. So the Ministry of the food better come up with some regulatory policies on this matter, gaurantee that the fishes sold in the market places do not contain toxic forms of formalin.
March 11th, 2007 at 11:54 am
Thanks Zafa, for this applied sciece information and it’s very vital piece of info, due to current spooky market ambience created by greedy fish-marketeers.
March 11th, 2007 at 1:54 pm
“Macheh Bhathey Bangali”
I think this is a corruption against our culture and heritage.
March 11th, 2007 at 2:32 pm
Formalin in fish, palm oil in soyabean, and who knows what in beef, chicken, eggs and fruit, esp when imported.
TALLOW, another toxic additive used in making soap & detergents, is also apparently used in adulterated veggy oil in BD.
Corruption has many arms, and destroys a nation in more ways than money. BNP started a bhejal-food drive once, then got side-tracked by other power-related corruption news.
Strong action is needed against food adulterators.
March 11th, 2007 at 4:31 pm
Zafa, thanks for the very valuable info. Without regulation it seems the profit motive rules.
Does anyone remember the scandal with Australian vetch masquerading as daal?
http://www.abc.net.au/rn/talks/8.30/helthrpt/stories/s22429.htm
March 12th, 2007 at 7:44 am
This kind of thing makes me want to throttle those responsible. It shows a business class that doesnt care at all whether their customers live or die. This worries me more than terrorism.
Regulating it would mean a lot of real time testing. Maybe someone can thing up some easy chemical tests? What we really need is the ability and knowledge to be able to see the signs, excess redness in the gills of fish etc. The consumers movement of bangladesh (DP should link with them).
March 12th, 2007 at 8:23 am
Fareed Zakaria of Newsweek also wants to talk about adaptation strategies.
http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/17080934/site/newsweek/
March 12th, 2007 at 8:37 am
Yes, you all are very right, adulterated food is a serious problem.
Mash, thanks for the link to vatch – I didn’t know about this one!
Fug, it is a very good idea that you mentioned – in fact there are some EPA approved ecological assessments procedures that involve visual inspections to identify if a certain species is under stress. Those tests can be modified and used to train the fish inspectors.
We all know about the urea tainted muri. Shaikh Shiraj (Channel i) did a good job aterting people on this matter.
I read in the paper that one ‘chanachur’ factory was frying the chanachur (a very common and popular snack) in mobil (motor oil). You might ask isn’t motor oil expensive as well? Not if it’s the spent oil. Spent motor oil are supposed to be discurded appropriately because it has all sorts of extremely hazardous petroleum bi-products. And the smell is repugnant.
Some methods of adulteration are too subtle to be detected by smell or appearance. A CDC nurse once told me not to eat watermelon while in Dhaka because they had reports that claimed some fruit vendors inject unsanitary water to increase the weight of the melons. I would have never guessed that!
March 12th, 2007 at 8:38 am
Here in Washington DC, me and my family have totally given up imported fishes from Bangladesh and South East Asia because of formalin scare. I would not count on Food and agriculture department to detect Formalin in imported fish for me. So my question is does anyone know of any commercially available Formalin detection kit?
March 12th, 2007 at 8:54 am
Friends,
Formalin for fishes and then we hear that some chemicals are used to keep fruits and vegs fresh upto 3/4 days–thats one reason for price hike in the markets.What kind of chemical would that be? Besides price hike the shop-keepers have developed a tendency to cheat in weights(except departmentals). It seems that customers are not safe buying these but still it needs to be bought and eaten to suvive.
Another dangersous thing is availability of meat in markets but one is not sure if the slaughtered animal was alive or dead and there is no dearth of “dui nomberi” things in the market which shopkeepers sell– they have no morality –only thing concerned is earning the money. Some drives were made by Rokunuddin Dowla and others but thats not sufficient- it would take a lot more teams n this drives and fines wont help what it needs is to pick up one for some severe punishments publicly;then sent to jail. Another thing thats urgently required si for costomers to refuse to buy– if they begin to do that the shopkeepers would become alert.Remember one doesnt die from not eating; we observe fasting and we can prolong that– Water is the best for life n some fruits.
March 12th, 2007 at 11:07 am
Just to give some idea formalin content in marine produce should not exceed 100 parts per million (ppm). In a market survey conducted in Malaysia the level of formalin found in fish on average was 2000 ppm – 20 times more than the allowable limit.
Hasibul (#8);
There are test kits available, but not necessarily targeted for home use, rather for laboratory uses – that comes with test strip and reagents. The change in color in the strips indicates the range of concentration of formalin.
In Malaysia a professor and her team had been awarded for coming up with a kit that helps measure formalin concentration in fish – not sure if it had been produced commercially yet.
March 12th, 2007 at 6:24 pm
who is the professor, please post details.
March 13th, 2007 at 6:16 am
I believe that some set has been handed to Rokonuddin so that he can easily test formalin in the market-question is how is going to be present in all markets- besides this there is no moral feeling on these sellers who also bring in fish that are already dead n sell them at low pricesand the very poor class do buy them.0nly in one matket I was able to drive that fisherman away and ensured that the poor didnt buy;but that was possible because the whole group of buyers n sellers agreed to the danger and supported the cause- but its not possible everytime as most time the shopkeeper ask me to move on if i dont intend to buy.I am not afraid of any threat from the fisher man(he does indicate the threat) what I am most worried is that people who understand the danger still buy them saying the poor stomach has more power than mine and that they wont die that soon; so unfortunately this unholy practise goes on.
Its time that this CA n his advisers arrange more groups and announce tyhrough mikes,TV that prices must come down and that fresh goods must be sold and offenders who sell stale food or anykind of food danger for consumption will be hauled in for prison.0nly then there will be change
March 13th, 2007 at 12:45 pm
‘The poor stomach has more power than the mind’ (or i’d say soul)
This is always the logic used by people who do wrong because of poverty. Its part of the common sense. Was this line of thinking present in our fathers and grand mothers generation, when they were young, and arguably poorer?
The adulterated foods issue blows my mind. yes i am well fed, but that doesnt mean im wrong right?
March 14th, 2007 at 10:14 am
i am very much thankfull for this very precise but informative article. i am student of Pharmacy. this is a fantastic article written like a story that never bores the reader. i want ZaFa doing these things a lot and regularly.
N.B: two of the professors from Dhaka University are angaged in making a system to ditect the formalin level,recently. a kit has been managed by the mobile court that is investigating this case.
June 16th, 2007 at 4:29 am
Very informative but very scary. In the Philippines, chinese businessmen import fruits from china which contain formalin. Too bad very few consumers know about this. Even the health organization in the philippines has not investigated on this matter.
November 16th, 2007 at 9:52 am
kindly inform us the test kit maker in malaysia and bangladesh for testing formalin in veddie/fruits/foods/fish/meats–>see zafa #10.
is it common in indonesia to apply formalin to preserve food/fish/meat/veggie even in foreign supermarket in indonesia such as ; carrefour/france, hypermarkt /usa.
pls help us to test formaline in foods/veggie/fish/meats
July 19th, 2008 at 5:22 am
This is an interesting article but just to point out something. I am pretty sure common rubbing alcohol in America is a solution of water and Isopropyl Alcohol aka Isopropanol and not Methyl Alcohol. I am pretty sure thats Methanol which is used as a common solvent in lab settings.