Mostafa Shiblee
Mostafa Shiblee is one of those
pioneers of change who start to solve a problem from
the moment they perceive it. The first time I met him
was in Washington DC on the opening night of the Common
Futures Forum, a global network of social entrepreneurs.
He was pouring tea, and I said "youre Mostafa"
- he smiled and said, "call me Shiblee". I
was about to learn the inspiring story of this small
mans persistent efforts at social transformation
in Bangladesh.
During his student years in Dhaka,
Shiblee watched in frustration and
sadness as thousands of students, including many friends,
took to drug addiction, rampaging in the streets, destroying
public property, and even killing each other. His own
studies were seriously affected by the violence and
apathy of Bangladeshi student life, and the forced closing
of his University because of student disturbances prolonged
the length of his own education from four to eight years.
The previously powerful and passionate student movement
was in a mess, confusing activism with violence. A badly
managed Western system of education designed for the
elite was worsening this situation. The promotion of
an obedient citizen was being imposed on a culture for
whom it had little relevance or meaning. Shiblee dreamed
of making a difference, of changing the current model
of education. The tool he knew best was his gift for
debate, which had won him many prizes.
In 1991, when the establishment
of Bangladesh's first democratic government opened the
door for change, Shiblee's dream went into high gear.
He set out to establish a system of parliamentary debates
to teach high school students to identify and analyse
their country's problems, develop thoughtful, imaginative
methods to solve them and learn about conflict resolution.
By learning these things before they got to university,
they could restore a constructive student activism based
on social responsibility and develop a new generation
of leaders in a democratic society. They would also
improve listening skills and independent thinking, the
essence of quality education in the modern world. Shiblee
saw the schools as the leverage point for social transformation
- the point where young people come together, where
they develop their values and social behaviour. At the
same time, he understood the effort embodied in bringing
debate clubs into a school system with no experience
in organised extra-curricular activities. Looming was
the far larger challenge of social transformation required
to incorporate democratic skills in a country with so
few years of democratic experience.
But Shiblee's combination of determination
and faith in people - rather than systems or institutions
- kept him going.
In 1995, a stipend from the Ashoka
foundation, and income generated from his own flourishing
business venture a matchmaking (marriage) agency,
gave Shiblee the resources to carry out Stage I of his
project. Operating as a team of one in 12 schools in
Dhaka City, where he had convinced local authorities
to try out the program, Shiblee worked endless hours
over the next two years, wading through the bureaucracy,
filling out papers, negotiating with prospective donors,
and of course developing and testing a
program with students and teachers.
In December 1997, funds from the
Norwegian Government permitted him to enlarge his effort
to 24 schools and 20,000 students. These schools were
specifically chosen because they were the most in need:
crowded (at least 1,000 students in each), with a low-income
population and evidence of violence, drugs, and other
unhealthy behaviour. His venture grew to a staff of
13, as he established an NGO called Working for a Better
Life (WBL) which administered the full-scale program,
entitled Debate for Social Change.
The overall positive response of
school authorities surprised Shiblee. "Most,"
he says, "instantly accepted our offer, readily
encouraged us to work with the students. But there were
some officials who exhibited a more covert form of resistance.
They could not argue," he said, "about the
program's ethical or educational value. So they dragged
their feet and blamed the bureaucracy. Teachers and
headmasters 'forgot' or cancelled appointments. They
told me they had more important things to do and that
the students couldn't really afford the time."
But Shiblee was persistent, and eventually WBL'S spreading
reputation brought a large number of requests by authorities,
teachers and students in other schools to be included
in the program.
One of Shiblees most important
lessons was how teachers are victimised, and are carrying
a huge untapped potential. Though a number remained
uninterested, he was duly impressed by the voluntary
spirit and keen desire for social change within this
low-paid profession. "They never refuse our requests
for help; they always manage to arrange a debate class;
they urge the students to participate and have more
and more become involved in helping them do research
and discuss the issues. They actually thank us for taking
this initiative and apologise for being unable to offer
such a program on their own."
Broader societal links have been
built into the program as judges for the final debate
are drawn from government officials, school authorities
and parental groups. Following the final debate, the
students prepare and send legislative and policy proposals
to Parliament. Shiblee is enthusiastic about how spontaneously
the students have taken hold of this component. For
example, students debating on garbage management met
with the Mayor of Dhaka with a proposal to privatise
the cleaning.
A debate on drug addiction spawned
a volley of proposals from students that included identification
of drug addicts among their friends, counselling, and
meetings with local police to curb the black market
availability. A group of girls put forth a plan to set
up a school garden nursery to generate income from renting
out plants for parties, public events and holiday celebrations
that would help pay for books and materials for the
clubs.
Shiblee has had many challenges,
but he has also overcome them. He is smiling. His long-cherished
dream will come true the day the schools take over the
program, and the program becomes sustainable with WBL
serving as a valuable resource.
Shiblee can think of no greater
reward than to put himself out of business.
- By Mille Bojer. (Parts of this article are
inspired by a recent article in the Changemakers journal
of the Ashoka foundation. For more information on Ashoka,
see www.ashoka.org)
|